Bounced 3rd K

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

My point was that there is no "out" rule for helmets in NFHS, but there is in ASA. And I agree, it should only apply if risk involved.

NFHS does not mention safety or risk, only intent. But, it is only a warning, too. If repeated, offender & head coach are restricted to the bench.

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by Bluefoot

I've talked to other blues who've said that they will call the BR out as soon as she turns and heads for the team area. But I do not think that is correct, since no play is being made on her, she is free to take any path she wants to 1B. Even if it starts toward her dugout. (if she enters the team area, I know that she is out) Do any of you rule BR's out for this, that is, starting to go towards dugout, and is that correct? (when no play is being made on BR)

The NFHS rule on abandonment is subtly different from ASA.

ASA says the runner is out "When a runner abandons a base and enters the team area or leaves live ball territory." (8-7-U)

NFHS says the runner is out when "She abandons a base, enters her team area or leaves the field of play." (8-6-22)

Other than the gender specificity, do you see the difference? Even with this difference, though, your "other blues" are awfully quick on the trigger. You still have to make the judgment that the runner did abandon the base, not merely turn another direction.