Is this a LBR violation?

[Dakota]

Don't know about fair, but...

Originally Posted by WestMichBlue

B1 hits ball to outfield, misses 1B, and beats the throw into 2B. Ball is returned to F1 in the circle. F3 is calling for the ball, claiming B-R missed the base.

R1 (former B-R, former B1) realizes her error and breaks for 1B.

Would you call a LBR violation?

What did F1 do in response to F3's calling for the ball? Was it enough motion to be considered "making a play" (ASA: caused the runner to react). If F1 is just standing there looking confused, LBR violation. If F1 is beginning to make the play, not a LBR violation.

Originally Posted by WestMichBlue

... would you then allow the defense's request for time to make a dead ball appeal, thus not risking a throw?

If playing action has ceased, yes. This is not using the LBR to aid the defense, the runner committed the base-running violation and found herself stranded and unable to correct her error.