Please take this quiz

[youngump]

Originally Posted by jmkupka

apologies for the confusion, youngump... my ruling is based on the premise that the umpire did enter the change on the line-up sheet (between innings, and before the play in question), but failed to notify the opposing coach.

Your clarification raises an interesting tangential play to my mind.

Lineup is submitted with two players left off; 1 & 2. In the 3rd inning, 1 is entered for 3 and the umpire fails to note that 1 wasn't on the card or to report it. Then in the 5th inning 2 enters for 4 and the umpire correctly warns, enters, and reports. Now in the seventh the defense protests that 1 is illegally in for 3. Would you restrict?

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by youngump

Your clarification raises an interesting tangential play to my mind.

Lineup is submitted with two players left off; 1 & 2. In the 3rd inning, 1 is entered for 3 and the umpire fails to note that 1 wasn't on the card or to report it. Then in the 5th inning 2 enters for 4 and the umpire correctly warns, enters, and reports. Now in the seventh the defense protests that 1 is illegally in for 3. Would you restrict?

the umpire fails to note that 1 wasn't on the card

or to report it.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by youngump

Your clarification raises an interesting tangential play to my mind.

Lineup is submitted with two players left off; 1 & 2. In the 3rd inning, 1 is entered for 3 and the umpire fails to note that 1 wasn't on the card or to report it. Then in the 5th inning 2 enters for 4 and the umpire correctly warns, enters, and reports. Now in the seventh the defense protests that 1 is illegally in for 3. Would you restrict?

Do you mean unreported or illegal for some other reason.
Unreported sub is now in the game, should have been noted as unreported.

The defense can protest an unreported sub as long as they are in the game.
So, yes, restrict and hope they have another sub or #3 can re-enter.

[youngump]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

Do you mean unreported or illegal for some other reason.
Unreported sub is now in the game, should have been noted as unreported.

The defense can protest an unreported sub as long as they are in the game.
So, yes, restrict and hope they have another sub or #3 can re-enter.

No, I mean as in the OP the coach reported the sub but the umpire didn't write it down or notice that 1 was not a legal substitute. Note only the coach is restricted for changing the lineup not the player so this won't cause them to have to substitute. (Which is good because who would you make them take out?)