Initial Play SNAFU

[Manny A]

Originally Posted by Dakota

Of course it is only one part, but you stated they did not recognize step and reach. They are one of the few who actually put this theory into black-letter rule.
That is your real objection, right, not the step and reach?

Well, I suppose. What I really meant (and did say at the end) was that the "step and reach" should apply to all fielders, including the pitcher. I don't understand why they feel a deflection off the pitcher should be treated differently than a deflection off anyone else. A runner shouldn't be held accountable for not knowing that the ball was deflected off the pitcher, when she's not held accountable should it deflect off the first baseman playing in for the bunt. Just equate "initial play" with "step and reach" for everyone.