force out appeal

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by Altor

I think this is an example:

Bases loaded, two outs. Batter hits a ball in the gap that scores 2, but R2 misses third on the way to the plate. BR is thrown out at 2nd. Defense also appeals the missed base. R2 is out, run does not score. But, the preceding runner does score because both the third and fourth outs were timing plays.

vs.

Bases loaded, two outs. Batter hits a ball in the gap for a clean double, but R2 misses third on the way to the plate. Defense appeals the missed base. R2 is out, run does not score. In this case though, the out on R2 is also a force play which means the preceding runner does not score either.

Altor:

You are correct in your second play but incorrect in your first play.

No runs score. See NFHS Softball R9-S1-A1d and e.

MTD, Sr.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.

Altor:

You are correct in your second play but incorrect in your first play.

No runs score. See NFHS Softball R9-S1-A1d and e.

MTD, Sr.

How so? There was no force out based on the accurate statement made in the OP?

[Altor]

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr:

The OP is ASA, not NFHS.

[chapmaja]

Originally Posted by Altor

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr:

The OP is ASA, not NFHS.

Agreed. From what I recall ASA considers the appeal of a force out a timing play. NFHS on the other hand considers the appeal of a force out to be a force out, thus negating any runs that score if the appealed force out is the 3rd out of the inning.

There was a case play IIRC (or maybe a test question), that read as follows:

R1 on 3rd, R2 on second, R1 on first, with 2 outs.

B6 his a ball into the corner and advances all the way to home plate. R2 missed third base. The defense properly appealed the missed base.

Ruling: R2 is out on a force out, and no runs score.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by chapmaja

Agreed. From what I recall ASA considers the appeal of a force out a timing play. NFHS on the other hand considers the appeal of a force out to be a force out, thus negating any runs that score if the appealed force out is the 3rd out of the inning.

There was a case play IIRC (or maybe a test question), that read as follows:

R1 on 3rd, R2 on second, R1 on first, with 2 outs.

B6 his a ball into the corner and advances all the way to home plate. R2 missed third base. The defense properly appealed the missed base.

Ruling: R2 is out on a force out, and no runs score.

You are quoting an NFHS ruling, apparently??

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

You are quoting an NFHS ruling, apparently??

NFHS Case Book Rule: 9.1.1 situations J and several others after... NFHS definitely considers the appeal of a missed base to which the runner was forced to be a force out, even after the fact.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Dakota

NFHS Case Book Rule: 9.1.1 situations J and several others after... NFHS definitely considers the appeal of a missed base to which the runner was forced to be a force out, even after the fact.

I was just needling Chap for not identifying it.

[youngump]

Originally Posted by Dakota

NFHS Case Book Rule: 9.1.1 situations J and several others after... NFHS definitely considers the appeal of a missed base to which the runner was forced to be a force out, even after the fact.

The only relevant case play which makes NFHS and ASA different is 9.1.1-O In that play, B4 is out before R2 is appealed for missing the forced base and it is still treated as a force. In all of the other case plays, the BR is not out and therefore the result would be the same as in ASA.

In other words, ASA considers an appeal of a missed base to which a runner was forced to be a force out if the force is in effect at the time of the appeal. And NFHS considers an appeal of a missed base to which a runner was forced to be a force out if the force was in effect at the time of the miss.

The NFHS choice raises an interesting TWP. Runners on the corners with 1 out and R2 (a very poor base runner) stealing. BR hits it hard 5-3 and R2 aggressively turns at 2nd missing the base. F3 fires to second and a run down ensues. In the confusion R2 realize she can't make it back to second and instead scrambles toward first. After another unsuccessful rundown, R2 is now standing safely on first. The defensive coach then instructs his players to appeal that R2 missed second base. Does the run count? Does it matter if the coach knows that he's appealing the initial miss or the return?

[josephrt1]

I would say if I'm not sure what they are appealing, I have to ask. This one I probably would not have asked and just honored the appeal. I've had coaches yell 'I'm making an appeal'. Coach what are you appealing?

I've also had a runner touch the white base before the ball arrived. No physical contact so no interference. Called her safe and the girl stood on the base with the ball. runner returned to 1st. Coach calls time and comes out to appeal she touched the white base. OK coach but she returned before you appealed. My 1st baseman stayed on the base because she was appealing. Sorry coach, she gave me no indication she was making an appeal before the runner returned.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by chapmaja

Agreed. From what I recall ASA considers the appeal of a force out a timing play.

That is not true. If the out effected was a force at the time of the appeal, it is still considered a force out.

NFHS on the other hand considers the appeal of a force out to be a force out, thus negating any runs that score if the appealed force out is the 3rd out of the inning.

It is a matter of when the force is in effect, not that ASA ignores it.

There was a case play IIRC (or maybe a test question), that read as follows:

R1 on 3rd, R2 on second, R1 on first, with 2 outs.

That R1 must be a helluva player

B6 his a ball into the corner and advances all the way to home plate. R2 missed third base. The defense properly appealed the missed base.

Ruling: R2 is out on a force out, and no runs score.

Same for ASA & NFHS

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Same for ASA & NFHS

Because the force was never removed.