overrunning first base and look back rule

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally posted by greymule
That part is clear to me, too. Until the batter has touched 1B and the pitcher has the ball in the circle, what the runners do is immaterial for the purposes of the look-back rule.

I do believe there is some ambiguity regarding Part c, however.

Ball in the circle. Runner overruns, turns left, makes a motion toward 2B and stops. Part c says (literally) that, now that she has stopped, she must proceed toward 2B non-stop. In what other situation can a runner stop between bases and not have a choice of which way to run?

A runner is either (1) permitted to stop and then immediately proceed one way or the other, or (2) not permitted to stop at all. Part c says a runner can stop but then must proceed in one direction only. I suspect that "and stops" should be deleted from Part c.

POE #33 (look-back rule) even contradicts Part c: "If, after the pitcher has the ball within the circle, the runner [who has overrun] starts back to the original base or forward to another base and then stops or reverses direction, the runner is out, unless the pitcher makes a play on the runner [it should say any runner].

POE #33 contains an known erroneous sentence. Perhaps Part c also fails to say what it means.

Read the rest of the rule. Part "d" stipulates that a runner who over-runs first and steps in any direction other than toward 2B, is committed to that base.

Rule 8.7.T.3.a-e are "rules" specifically designed for the BR (this is used to distiguish the last batter from other activer runners). And I do not see where POE #33 contradicts Part c. Your so called "quote" above is not verbatim and it seems you have taken the liberty to insert what you believe them to be. The sentence you "quoted" refers to the "runner", not the BR as in the previous paragraph.