The Official Forum > Search Forums Search Results

User Name Remember Me? Password

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 > Last »

Showing results 26 to 50 of 125 Search took 0.00 seconds; generated 105 minute(s) ago. Search: Posts Made By: cookie

Forum: Baseball Thu Jun 14, 2012, 10:36pm

Replies: 39 Last Play of the Game Question Views: 6,635 Posted By cookie "Also, if R1 or R2 should abandon his base path... "Also, if R1 or R2 should abandon his base path after either one has passed 2nd or 3rd respectively and either is called out before R3 crosses the plate (time play), then R3's run will not count. So...

Forum: Baseball Thu Jun 14, 2012, 04:06pm

Replies: 39 Last Play of the Game Question Views: 6,635 Posted By cookie "...For example, the defense won't be able... "...For example, the defense won't be able to...prevent a HR with bases loaded from scoring the winning run as long as (as worded in 4.09(b)) R3 and BR advance and touch home plate and 1B." I...

Forum: Baseball Tue Jun 12, 2012, 11:38am

Replies: 39 Last Play of the Game Question Views: 6,635 Posted By cookie My understanding (via Jacksa/Roder during relaxed... My understanding (via Jacksa/Roder during relaxed action) is that if the force was in place when the missed base occurred, then the order doesn't matter as long as it's the 3rd out in order to negate...

Forum: Baseball Thu Jun 07, 2012, 10:39pm

Replies: 39 Last Play of the Game Question Views: 6,635 Posted By cookie If the batted ball is thrown in from the outfield... If the batted ball is thrown in from the outfield directly to 2nd base for a force out (unrelaxed action), then the order of put outs will matter as the force of R2 has been removed. R2 will now have...

Forum: Baseball Thu Jun 07, 2012, 10:14pm

Replies: 39 Last Play of the Game Question Views: 6,635 Posted By cookie Since this situation involves a batted ball ("hit... Since this situation involves a batted ball ("hit to OF") not an award, the appeal plays at 2nd and 3rd are still valid in OBR. R1 must touch second and R2 must touch 3rd - the bases to which they...

Forum: Baseball Thu May 03, 2012, 07:56am

Replies: 32 Tim Welke - missed call Views: 4,629 Posted By cookie Welke obviously didn't adjust for the off throw;... Welke obviously didn't adjust for the off throw; otherwise, he would have clearly seen the "way pulled" foot. As I have been told, "Get back to fundamentals..."

Forum: Baseball Thu May 03, 2012, 04:36am

Replies: 20 OBS then INT Views: 3,428 Posted By cookie thumpferee: "...I wanted to add as celebur... thumpferee: "...I wanted to add as celebur mentioned and that I find it hard to give him 3rd on a base hit to RF. Unless BR was knocked down, it sounds like he was nailed at 3rd and needed to...

Forum: Baseball Thu May 03, 2012, 03:46am

Replies: 9 Appeal of OBS Runner's Missed Base Views: 1,943 Posted By cookie Later that Tuesday afternoon I found what I was... Later that Tuesday afternoon I found what I was looking for in the 2011 BRD - Section 346 - page 241: Fed - no provision (treat as in NCAA); NCAA - point not covered (however, there is official...

Forum: Baseball Tue May 01, 2012, 10:16am

Replies: 20 OBS then INT Views: 3,428 Posted By cookie For Fed, I'll go along with what Welpe has... For Fed, I'll go along with what Welpe has posted. For OBR, I had something somewhat similar happen to me in a "controlled game" play at the Umpire School, and I was told that the INT trumped the...

Forum: Baseball Tue May 01, 2012, 09:54am

Replies: 8 Interference at 2nd? 1 out or 2? Views: 1,673 Posted By cookie What's FPSR? Force Play Slide Rule What's FPSR? Force Play Slide Rule

Forum: Baseball Tue May 01, 2012, 09:37am

Replies: 9 Appeal of OBS Runner's Missed Base Views: 1,943 Posted By cookie Appeal of OBS Runner's Missed Base Jaksa/Roder has: "If a runner misses a base because of obstruction, an appeal of his missed base cannot be upheld." However, they do not give any examples of such plays, nor do they cite any explicit...

Forum: Baseball Tue May 01, 2012, 09:28am

Replies: 8 Interference at 2nd? 1 out or 2? Views: 1,673 Posted By cookie Under Fed Rules, it appears to be a FPSR... Under Fed Rules, it appears to be a FPSR violation. If the pop-up slide (not allowed in Fed FPSR) altered the play in any way, then R1 is out AND BR is out. Obviously, the ball hitting R1's helmut...

Forum: Baseball Wed Dec 28, 2011, 03:49am

Replies: 10 NCAA Obstruction Views: 2,132 Posted By cookie Just to confirm my own understanding of this... Just to confirm my own understanding of this situation: R1 could be awarded home if the umpire judged that R1 could have scored, even though R1 had retreated back to third. (I have heard some...

Forum: Baseball Tue Oct 11, 2011, 01:58am

Replies: 31 Umpire "Etiquette" Views: 7,917 Posted By cookie Thanks everyone for your responses. I will now... Thanks everyone for your responses. I will now follow through with a handshake with my partner well off the field for the concerns mentioned above (though I wonder why it has been 6 years for someone...

Forum: Baseball Sun Oct 09, 2011, 09:44pm

Replies: 31 Umpire "Etiquette" Views: 7,917 Posted By cookie Umpire "Etiquette" A couple of things I'd like to ask you umpires who've umpiring a long time (way more than my 6 years) (1) Oftentime upon completion of a game I would shake the hand of my partner as we were...

Forum: Baseball Fri Oct 07, 2011, 08:06pm

Replies: 15 Foul then fair Views: 3,972 Posted By cookie Steve Tyler: "...David Murphy was at bat, and... Steve Tyler: "...David Murphy was at bat, and didn't get a hit. He struck out swinging on a wild pitch..." A review of the box score indeed indicates what you said, Steve. I had just...

Forum: Baseball Sun Oct 02, 2011, 02:28am

Replies: 15 Foul then fair Views: 3,972 Posted By cookie Larry 1953: "So now PU Danley completely kicks a... Larry 1953: "So now PU Danley completely kicks a call on a dribbler in front of the plate." Regarding the dribbler in front of the plate that plate umpire Danley called "Foul", replay clearly...

Forum: Baseball Sun Oct 02, 2011, 02:09am

Replies: 15 Foul then fair Views: 3,972 Posted By cookie Umpjim: "Did I see the LFU signal foul then fair... Umpjim: "Did I see the LFU signal foul then fair in top of the 2nd in the TX TB game?" Yes, you did; I saw it, too (via TNT). It sure looked like he (Marv Hudson?) signaled "Time", then quickly...

Forum: Baseball Fri Sep 16, 2011, 06:48pm

Replies: 6 Ball and Balk Views: 1,981 Posted By cookie I though in addition to calling the failure to... I though in addition to calling the failure to wipe a "ball"; therefore, Ball 4 in this case, the umpire would request a new ball to put into play. Or is this "over the top?"

Forum: Baseball Sat Sep 10, 2011, 09:48am

Replies: 27 Half Swing Strikes Views: 5,145 Posted By cookie So does that also mean that U3 has the option now... So does that also mean that U3 has the option now of position C or B with a runner on 1st base with or without a LH batter at the plate? I believe it is mandatory for U3 to be in the C position when...

Forum: Baseball Sat Sep 03, 2011, 09:05pm

Replies: 1 3-Man Mechanics Views: 1,507 Posted By cookie 3-Man Mechanics There are 5 possible situations for rotation of plate umpire to 3rd on a batted ball that leaves the infield. However, is the possible rotation restricted to just a batted ball? (1) Would there...

Forum: Baseball Tue Jun 21, 2011, 10:53pm

Replies: 11 Fake Tag in Am. Legion Game Views: 3,460 Posted By cookie Thanks men for the reponses. I had the... Thanks men for the reponses. I had the opportunity this evening to talk with a veteran umpire who has done many American Legion games here in New York. He knows of no fake tag rule within the...

Forum: Baseball Tue Jun 21, 2011, 03:22am

Replies: 11 Fake Tag in Am. Legion Game Views: 3,460 Posted By cookie Fake Tag in Am. Legion Game I recently watched an American Legion game (Sr) where there was a fake tag at 2nd base. R1 and a wild pitch (backstop pretty far back). F2 did not throw, but F6 made a fake tag onto the sliding...

Forum: Baseball Fri May 20, 2011, 02:45am

Replies: 32 Rules Question Views: 5,693 Posted By cookie "...left his base and went to the dugout." ... "...left his base and went to the dugout." It's my understanding that if R3 entered the dugout, it is definitely "Abandonment;" therefore R3 is out just for that - no tag necessarry. (Some might...

Forum: Baseball Mon May 09, 2011, 01:20am

Replies: 51 Wakefield, Hernandez, Francona and West Views: 7,852 Posted By cookie "...but I think it is the right call based on the... "...but I think it is the right call based on the video. " How many of us really get the opportunity to review a balk in video before making a call? No one. We get a one-shot deal... I probably...

Showing results 26 to 50 of 125

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 > Last »

Forum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Baseball Basketball Football Softball General / Off-Topic Hockey Lacrosse Rugby Soccer Swimming/Diving Track & Field Volleyball Wrestling Feedback Testing Forum