New kickoff rule

[HLin NC]

See further discussion here:

2014 Comments on football rules changes...

[IAUMP]

I'm from Iowa and we experimented with this rule for a couple of years. I don't remember one game that we had to enforce a penalty for there not being 4 on each side of the kicker. Also, while this may have changed, we were told that the penalty applied happened when the ball was kicked.

[JRutledge]

I wonder who calls this in high school or at least in 5 person mechanics? In 7 man/person, right now the Referee is the primary on this, but then again they are in the middle of the field. It is not impossible to call this from other positions, but we could get screened as to who is on which side of the ball if you are looking from the sideline.

Peace

[Texas Aggie]

I have not called this once in games under NCAA rules where its been forever. I think its a live ball foul like offsides (in NCAA), but I'd have to check. Generally, on long kickoffs, you should pretty much ignore it anyway. Tell the coach to get it fixed and maybe flag it if they keep doing it. For short kickoffs and onsides you need to strictly enforce it.

I think they changed our mechanic in Texas to where the R, either at the pylon or in the center of the field, depending on how many officials and what mechanic choice the crew makes, makes the call.

[bisonlj]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I wonder who calls this in high school or at least in 5 person mechanics? In 7 man/person, right now the Referee is the primary on this, but then again they are in the middle of the field. It is not impossible to call this from other positions, but we could get screened as to who is on which side of the ball if you are looking from the sideline.

Peace

I agree with Texas Aggie. If the kick is deep don't worry about it as much. If it's an obvious onside kick where you put 4 guys in the box anyway move the R to the middle so he has a view of this. If they kick it deep you are going to be out of position anyway. If they do a surprise onside do the best you can with the guys in their normal position. You may or may not get it but that's the break with 5-man crews.