Charging vs. Player control

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Thought the main point in this thread was that a charge and a player control foul are not the same thing.

Sometimes they are. Sometimes they're not.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Sometimes they are. Sometimes they're not.

Absolutely true. No one argues (do they) that the two are not necessarily the same.


So how do we possibly get from this

What if one official signals a block and the other signals a player control foul, then what do we do?

to this?

Originally Posted by BillyMac

4.19.8 SITUATION C: A1 drives for a try and jumps and releases the ball.
Contact occurs between A1 and B1 after the release and before airborne shooter
A1 returns one foot to the floor. One official calls a blocking foul on B1 and the
other official calls a charging foul on A1. The try is (a) successful, or (b) not successful.
RULING: Even though airborne shooter A1 committed a charging foul, it
is not a player-control foul because the two fouls result in a double personal foul.
The double foul does not cause the ball to become dead on the try. In (a), the goal
is scored; play is resumed at the point of interruption, which is a throw-in for
Team B from anywhere along the end line. In (b), the point of interruption is a try
in flight; therefore the alternating-possession procedure is used. (4-36)

The question doesn't contain the word charge.
The case doesn't contain the words player control.

Let alone obligation based on signals which may or may not mean the same thing.

[Welpe]

This is like seeing magnesium being dumped in a swimming pool.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Welpe

This is like seeing magnesium being dumped in a swimming pool.

For some

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Welpe

This is like seeing magnesium being dumped in a swimming pool.

Did you mean to say Sodium, or Potassium?

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by just another ref

The case doesn't contain the words player control.

Because it's a double foul. If the other official didn't call a block, then it would have been a player control foul.