Help

[RandyBrown]

Originally Posted by AllPurposeGamer

For the most part, all things being equal, we call violations as we see them.

Originally Posted by AllPurposeGamer

I don't know if I'm more flexible...I agree with JR's assessment of this play fully.

JR doesn't use language like, "for the most part, all things being equal".

Originally Posted by AllPurposeGamer

I'm actually not sure what you're hung up on as far as grasping or A/D or intent. I've never heard anyone have an issue with the rule as written. Everyone knows what kind of "grasp" we're talking about on a dunk attempt that needs to be called a T. If you want to say we're reading into the "intent of the rules" then so be it.

I'm not hung up on anything. As I said, just curious whether there was a variety of opinion on the issue. I don't know why you two are having a problem accepting that, but let's not argue about it any longer. This has gone way beyond the scope of what I started.

[APG]

Originally Posted by RandyBrown

I'm not hung up on anything. As I said, just curious whether there was a variety of opinion on the issue. I don't know why you two are having a problem accepting that, but let's not argue about it any longer. This has gone way beyond the scope of what I started.

Fair enough I guess...wouldn't you say that the near universal opinion you've received on this play should satisfy your curiosity as to whether there are any dissenting opinions?