player control or not

[Freddy]

Originally Posted by AKOFL

. . . jumps to save it and throws it . . .

That's a previous point of contention here.
If you determined that he, in order to "throw it", obtained player control, then he also obtained team control and a violation has occurred in your sitch.
If you determined that no player control was assumed because he merely batted the ball, then no violation occurred.
I think that is what, based on the rules, the consensus arrived at.