Coach on the court

[Eastshire]

Originally Posted by CMHCoachNRef

This depends on the age and level of the players. For the younger kids games (more often in soccer, but occasionally in basketball), I actually go with a more positive statement. After analyzing what happened, if I don't think that there is an injury, but more of a player either hearing the parents' reaction or perhaps acting momentarily startled, I will make a simple statement. "You sure are tough, you look like you can still play. Do you want to stay in?" Nine times out of ten, the answer is either a nod or a soft "yes." Asking the real youngins usually leads to tears and being replaced.

On the other hand, in high school-aged games, I will typically wave the coach OFF the court/field until I have had a chance to ask the very question that you posed, grunewar. This gives the player a chance to be able to stay in the game.

If the coach insists on coming out, I insist on player removal per the rules. Once again, in the younger age groups I strongly encourage the coaches to wait for my signal -- in the event of a possible "real" injury, I am stopping the play quickly and beckoning the coach.

My association has instructed us to immediately beckon the coach anytime we think there might be an injury. We are specifically instructed not to approach the player and ask if they can play.

I think it's a bit of an extreme position but when in Rome.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Eastshire

My association has instructed us to immediately beckon the coach anytime we think there might be an injury. We are specifically instructed not to approach the player and ask if they can play.

I think it's a bit of an extreme position but when in Rome.

Really? Wow. I almost always ask the question before beckoning the coach.

Is that your association's response to the new concussed player rule?

I would think you'd have some upset coaches if this happens towards the end of some close games.

[Eastshire]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Really? Wow. I almost always ask the question before beckoning the coach.

Is that your association's response to the new concussed player rule?

I would think you'd have some upset coaches if this happens towards the end of some close games.

It's my first year with this association so I'm not sure if it's new or they've always done it that way. It does make it difficult to notice apparent signs of a concussion though and I've felt a bit of a "see no evil" mindset on the issue.