Three things to watch in a single play

[CLH]

1) Travel is to close to put a whistle on for me. If I'm gonna kill the game for a travel, its going to be clear and obvious. That one is just to close to clearly say, yep its a travel without the benefit of slow mo and all that crap. I'm not cracking a whistle on this one.

2) Flop

3) Rebounder had a height advantage and was able to reach over a shorter rebounder. Doesn't look like much to me from this angle, play on!

[tref]

Originally Posted by CLH

1) Travel is to close to put a whistle on for me. If I'm gonna kill the game for a travel, its going to be clear and obvious. That one is just to close to clearly say, yep its a travel without the benefit of slow mo and all that crap. I'm not cracking a whistle on this one.

I agree! I've been told that, if you have to rewind the play 3-5 times to see the travel its probably a GI. I dont call marginal travels...

[Adam]

Originally Posted by tref

I agree! I've been told that, if you have to rewind the play 3-5 times to see the travel its probably a GI. I dont call marginal travels...

Let me just say, the video here is too grainy to really know whether the travel is marginal, obvious, or non-existent.

You're right, though:
If he might have, he didn't.

[tref]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Let me just say, the video here is too grainy to really know whether the travel is marginal, obvious, or non-existent.

True

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Let me just say, the video here is too grainy to really know whether the travel is marginal, obvious, or non-existent.

There is only one way to definitively settle the matter. Have a poll!

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

There is only one way to definitively settle the matter. Have a poll!

Well, aren't you just the populist today.

[Judtech]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

There is only one way to definitively settle the matter. Have a poll!

Who should we get for this? Are we going to consider percieved bias? We would want them to "poll it both ways"? My first thought would to be use the Harris Poll. Since there is a tie in with both a coach (Del) and a player (Devin)