Quiz time for newbies

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

I've never seen it, called or no-called, so I have no opinion on how it's "traditionally" been called. I'll defer to you on that.

My initial thought was to call it a violation, but as I read the rule I questioned that based on the same thought process mbyron posted.

That thought process is wrong. He erroneously makes "up" an element of the rule.