Just a question....

[grunewar]

Originally Posted by adchris

If the contact was initiated by the offense, it should have been whistled an offensive foul. Simply because the defense is moving doesn't put the burden on the defender. It sounds as though the defender wasn't even aware the offensive player was even approaching and essentially was run over by the dribbler. Call: Player control foul on A1, ball to team B at nearest spot, no free throws if in bonus.

So, after the contact, B1 is standing their saying, "who me?" and A1 is on the floor and lost the ball.

And your call is foul on A1? What advantage was gained by A1 that you would call them for the foul?

HTBT, but I either call a push on B1 or no call IMO.