Anyone ever called this?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by jkumpire

If the violation is to be enforced all the time, then the ball would become dead immediately.

Not true. See 6-7 Excp d.

This is a violation, not a foul. Please name for me a violation by the defense, not a foul, that allows both the score and the violation to be penalized.

Swinging the elbows and leaving the court.

Is this violation by the defense so bad that your penalize the defense by allowing the goal, and giving the offense the ball again? Is it really on the level of an intentional or technical foul?

I'm not quite sure what you are asking here. If you're asking what the rule *IS*, then you're wrong. If you're asking what the rule *SHOULD BE*, then I would tend to agree with you.