Signaling of Bonus

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by TimTaylor

Most all of our schools have provision on the scoreboard to indicate actual number of team fouls - I much prefer that to a simple bonus light. Even with either the bonus light or number of team fouls displayed, the reporting official should still look to the official scorekeeper for confirmation, which they are supposed to give per 2-11-10. I like to be proactive on bonus situations, so I usually ask the scorekeeper to let us know when each team hits 6 team fouls.

The big question is then: how many times does the official scorer actually signal the bonus without being asked?

Another question for everyone, do you prefer the player fouls being shown on the scoreboard, or should this just be up to the official book to keep track?

I rotate on the JV & C-Squad games on showing the player fouls on the scoreboard. Of course, I always keep track of the team fouls on the scoreboard.

When I was working scoreboard at 4A Regionals last February, we only kept track of the team fouls. It was up to the book to keep track of the player fouls.

[sseltser]

Originally Posted by chseagle

The big question is then: how many times does the official scorer actually signal the bonus without being asked?

It should happen everytime the bonus is in effect. I only ask when I have an "inkling" that we are at 7 or 10.

Originally Posted by chseagle

Another question for everyone, do you prefer the player fouls being shown on the scoreboard, or should this just be up to the official book to keep track?

No preference. I won't look up to see. If the teams / fans want it, that's good for them.

Originally Posted by chseagle

It was up to the book to keep track of the player fouls.

It always is. In fact, it's also always up to the book to keep track of team fouls. The only "official" part of the scoreboard is the time, provided it was designated the official timepiece by the referee. This is why the scoreboard operator is the "timer" and the person keeping the book is the "scorer."

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by sseltser

It should happen everytime the bonus is in effect. I only ask when I have an "inkling" that we are at 7 or 10.

I remember from when I was doing book, even if I was the visitors' scorebook, I'd always signal when bonus was in effect. I still do signal, even though not doing book.

Originally Posted by sseltser

No preference. I won't look up to see. If the teams / fans want it, that's good for them.

My reasoning for asking about the player fouls on the board, is basically as a second record (as the scoreboard controls my alma mater uses has memory built in to keep track of the player fouls), & also a way for the coach to keep track without having to ask the book all the time.

Originally Posted by sseltser

It always is. In fact, it's also always up to the book to keep track of team fouls. The only "official" part of the scoreboard is the time, provided it was designated the official timepiece by the referee. This is why the scoreboard operator is the "timer" and the person keeping the book is the "scorer."

Maybe I'll try that next time I do a game. Do nothing but the time on the scoreboard & let the book(s) get asked all the time about the score & the fouls.

Especially since, technically, all a timer has to do is keep track/tabs on the time in the game. Nowhere is it listed that the timer has to keep track of the score or fouls.

[truerookie]

[QUOTE=chseagle;646323]The big question is then: how many times does the official scorer actually signal the bonus without being asked?

Another question for everyone, do you prefer the player fouls being shown on the scoreboard, or should this just be up to the official book to keep track?

Not my duties to track individuals fouls, So, I will not be concerned if they do or not.

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by chseagle

The big question is then: how many times does the official scorer actually signal the bonus without being asked?

Another question for everyone, do you prefer the player fouls being shown on the scoreboard, or should this just be up to the official book to keep track?

I rotate on the JV & C-Squad games on showing the player fouls on the scoreboard. Of course, I always keep track of the team fouls on the scoreboard.

When I was working scoreboard at 4A Regionals last February, we only kept track of the team fouls. It was up to the book to keep track of the player fouls.

Originally Posted by truerookie

Not my duties to track individuals fouls, So, I will not be concerned if they do or not.

I was asking about the player fouls on the board, as I've seen it done in the past where the officials have noticed that the board lists a player with 5 fouls before the book says anything. So it can help expedite a game.

[JRutledge]

I hardly ever pay attention to the bonus on the table. And I always thought the light was pointed toward the bench. Then again, I do not pay attention to that in the first place. That is what the clock is for.

Peace

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I hardly ever pay attention to the bonus on the table. And I always thought the light was pointed toward the bench. Then again, I do not pay attention to that in the first place. That is what the clock is for.

Peace

Especially since not all tables have the setup for signaling the bonus. Very true about the scoreboard though about the bonus being lit appropriately.

[TimTaylor]

Originally Posted by chseagle

I was asking about the player fouls on the board, as I've seen it done in the past where the officials have noticed that the board lists a player with 5 fouls before the book says anything. So it can help expedite a game.

We're not concerned with tracking individual fouls. Whether or not they are displayed on the scoreboard is irrelevant as it's not official - by rule we have to be notified by the official book when a player DQ's on fouls, then there is a specific procedure that we must follow. A few seconds here or there isn't significant.

We really aren't concerned with tracking team fouls either, but it is useful to know when a team is getting close to the bonus or double bonus situation. That said, we still have to confirm it with the official book.

sseltser wasn't being facetious - with the exception of the time, everything else displayed on the scoreboard, while it may be useful, is not official. When push comes to shove, it's what is in the official book that counts.

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by TimTaylor

We're not concerned with tracking individual fouls. Whether or not they are displayed on the scoreboard is irrelevant as it's not official - by rule we have to be notified by the official book when a player DQ's on fouls, then there is a specific procedure that we must follow. A few seconds here or there isn't significant.

We really aren't concerned with tracking team fouls either, but it is useful to know when a team is getting close to the bonus or double bonus situation. That said, we still have to confirm it with the official book.

sseltser wasn't being facetious - with the exception of the time, everything else displayed on the scoreboard, while it may be useful, is not official. When push comes to shove, it's what is in the official book that counts.

Hence why in one of my earlier postings, I was saying that one of the times I'm doing scorebaord/timer, I'll just have the time displayed on the scoreboard & nothing else. This way the scorebook would have to be relied on 100%, instead of the coaches looking at the scoreboard for information.

[jdw3018]

Originally Posted by chseagle

Hence why in one of my earlier postings, I was saying that one of the times I'm doing scorebaord/timer, I'll just have the time displayed on the scoreboard & nothing else. This way the scorebook would have to be relied on 100%, instead of the coaches looking at the scoreboard for information.

No you won't.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by chseagle

Hence why in one of my earlier postings, I was saying that one of the times I'm doing scorebaord/timer, I'll just have the time displayed on the scoreboard & nothing else. This way the scorebook would have to be relied on 100%, instead of the coaches looking at the scoreboard for information.

Until I remove you, of course.

I'm spoiled, I guess. I work pretty much only varsity and juco ball these days, so we always have team fouls on the board. We signal each other at 6 and 9 and we're almost never surprised by a bonus situation.

I don't care about the bonus light on the scoreboard or at the table or at the reporting of the individual fouls on the board as I don't even look there.

[grunewar]

Originally Posted by chseagle

Hence why in one of my earlier postings, I was saying that one of the times I'm doing scorebaord/timer, I'll just have the time displayed on the scoreboard & nothing else.

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Until I remove you, of course.

And then of course he'd just move to "crowd control" and provide the coaches, trainer, table, parents, EMT's, ambulance drivers, and the officials "advice" for the rest of the game......

[Adam]

Originally Posted by chseagle

Hence why in one of my earlier postings, I was saying that one of the times I'm doing scorebaord/timer, I'll just have the time displayed on the scoreboard & nothing else. This way the scorebook would have to be relied on 100%, instead of the coaches looking at the scoreboard for information.

You're joking, right? I'm asking this before I tell you what I really think of this idea.

[chseagle]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

You're joking, right? I'm asking this before I tell you what I really think of this idea.

Yes I am joking. Although it wouldn't surprise me if no one noticed since we don't get large crowds for C-Squad games.

If I was to do it, it'd be during a C-Squad game.

[truerookie]

Originally Posted by chseagle

I was asking about the player fouls on the board, as I've seen it done in the past where the officials have noticed that the board lists a player with 5 fouls before the book says anything. So it can help expedite a game.

I will wait on the book to tell me before I take any actions.