Duke vs. Villanova

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by GoodwillRef

There was a very bad basket interference call against UConn also...really bad.

There was also a held ball with the arrow favoring the shooting team immediately following an air ball and they didn't reset the shot clock.

[biz]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

There was also a held ball with the arrow favoring the shooting team immediately following an air ball and they didn't reset the shot clock.

Wow! I've never thought about that one. Team control ends on the shot attempt so it's not remaining with the team in control, therefore reset. Do I have it figured out right, Scrapper?

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by biz

Wow! I've never thought about that one. Team control ends on the shot attempt so it's not remaining with the team in control, therefore reset. Do I have it figured out right, Scrapper?

Bingo! This was a test question for my D3 association several years in a row, so I have it down pat now.

[jalons]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

Bingo! This was a test question for my D3 association several years in a row, so I have it down pat now.

So you are resetting the shot clock when an offensive rebound occurs on an air ball??

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by jalons

So you are resetting the shot clock when an offensive rebound occurs on an air ball??

Can you read?

[Chess Ref]

Shot clock issues aside is anyone surprised at how rough that game was. I realize I'm no big dog. I don't watch that much college basketball. So you can treat me as a fanboy if you must. FYI I'm a Duke hater but man that is physical basketball going on.

I thought the Big Sky was thug ball but the Villanove players are bigger and stronger then Big Sky hoopers and I was a little more then surprised at how rough it was.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Chess Ref

Shot clock issues aside is anyone surprised at how rough that game was. I realize I'm no big dog. I don't watch that much college basketball. So you can treat me as a fanboy if you must. FYI I'm a Duke hater but man that is physical basketball going on.

I thought the Big Sky was thug ball but the Villanove players are bigger and stronger then Big Sky hoopers and I was a little more then surprised at how rough it was.

I know one thing, Villanova is not afraid to send you to the free throw line. One of their starters fouled out on a stupid foul with about 4 1/2 minutes left and the bench was laughing with him when he came off the court.

[grunewar]

Originally Posted by Chess Ref

Shot clock issues aside is anyone surprised at how rough that game was. I realize I'm no big dog. I don't watch that much college basketball. So you can treat me as a fanboy if you must. FYI I'm a Duke hater but man that is physical basketball going on.

I thought the Big Sky was thug ball but the Villanove players are bigger and stronger then Big Sky hoopers and I was a little more then surprised at how rough it was.

....and the Big East still has five teams standing (for now) out of the remaining 12 - a pretty healthy percentage.

[jalons]

Originally Posted by mbyron

Can you read?

I believe so.....

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by jalons

So you are resetting the shot clock when an offensive rebound occurs on an air ball??

Yes, as per the rules that I posted earlier. That's why you were asked if you could read -- the rule and its exceptions were posted in post #15 of this thread. The rule in question is NCAA Men's 2-11-6c.

[Jay R]

Originally Posted by jalons

So you are resetting the shot clock when an offensive rebound occurs on an air ball??

Only if the result is a held ball. A airball followed by an offensive rebound is not a reset. In fact, in the Pitt Xavier game; that's what happened on the missed shot clock violation.

[GoodwillRef]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

There was also a held ball with the arrow favoring the shooting team immediately following an air ball and they didn't reset the shot clock.

Why would you reset the shot clock?

[dahoopref]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

There was also a held ball with the arrow favoring the shooting team immediately following an air ball and they didn't reset the shot clock.

I didn't see this play but I think resetting the shot clock would only apply if the offense and defense grabbed the held ball simultaneously or if the defense had control of the ball first. If the offensive player got hold of the ball first then the shot clock stays when the held ball happened.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by dahoopref

I didn't see this play but I think resetting the shot clock would only apply if the offense and defense grabbed the held ball simultaneously or if the defense had control of the ball first.

This is exactly what happened.