![]() |
Quote:
|
Bob has already answered this...
Quote:
The correctable error we are talking about is when an official erroneously counts or disallows points. Remember the correctable errors are for officials setting aside a rule. If one official sees the foot on the line but the other official counts the basket as 3 points the crew as set aside a rule and counted pionts that were not earned. The scorekeeper can not set aside any rules, therefore, any mistakes in scoring made by them can be corrected until the officials jurisdiction ends. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I think not - you can get the score right in this situation, because the score has been recorded in the book it can be corrected to be a two or a three at any time. If it isn't in there you may have another issue, but once they write it down it is the scorer's fault whether it is or it isn't. |
You can only fix the score anytime durring the game if the scorekeeper writes down what is not signaled by the official. If he writes down what is signald by the official it needs to be corrected in the alloted amount of time for a correcable error. I think I wrote that right.:)
|
Quote:
2-11-11 " ... a bookkeeping mistake may be corrected at any time until the referee approves the final score ..." We're not talking bookkeeping here. |
Quote:
Bartender! |
Quote:
It is also encouraged locally that as the off-ball official (if you have a chance) take a peek at the feet on a try for 3. Sometimes the calling official is straight lined from seeing both feet. |
Quote:
I think you are wrong by the intent if not the actual rule, however the most important thing here is that you get the call right, period. If the scorer puts a score in the book and I know it is wrong - I am changing it to what it should be when I get the chance. I am authorized to do so becuase points were put in the book and "the scorer did it wrong". little off topic. Now how about the not counting a basket at all? in this day and age of computerized play by play (not all HS have this)/even most everyone has some radio or webcast going. last night BV there were four books, two statisticians, I do not think I could have lost a point if I wanted to. There is too much information available for you not to be able to correct a score with fairly accurate knowledge. This is one they should look at taking out of the correctable error line and just make it right the get the score or they do not. |
Quote:
Don't know if I want to be there too often -- dueling indications -- but it does create the opportunity later for wiggle room. Or as it's been written so many times before, like Bob said. |
Last weekend in southern Indiana. Ruled a three to win, 44-43.YouTube - Referee blows call big time
|
Quote:
|
So ....
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Some say whoever sees it fix it on the fly. Some say whoever sees it, blow your whistle to stop play and then correct the call. Others say whoever sees it, blow your whistle and give information to the primary for the primary to change or not change. And some others will say wait til the next dead ball... It needs to be pre-gamed. |
Quote:
I however advocate that if the score is wrong the score keep did it and I can correct the score right up until we walk out of the gym and thus approve the score. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:32pm. |