gps-8 what would you do?

[Mark Dexter]

Crew, how is this situation different than GPS #7 - "The Big Picture?"

[crew]

Originally posted by Mark Dexter
Crew, how is this situation different than GPS #7 - "The Big Picture?"

in the post gps-7, a foul had occurred, marginal, but yet a foul. i just blew who fouled who in my mind. the best play was to pass on the foul but i got very rattled and blew the hell out of it. i wish one of my partners would have come to me with info about out of bounds or something better, but that did not happen. i did not obviously miss a play, though i did miss it. the play gps-8 is an obvious miss with partners that recognized it and have the ability offer info to possibly bail out the calling official. no one knew to bail me out in gps-7.

[jpageref]

I agree that if you have definite knowledge that you should at least go to your partner and say 'I have information to add'. Then, let your partner decide. My question is, if the play is going to the hole between the T and the L, why is the Slot seeing it?

[Mark Dexter]

Originally posted by jpageref
I agree that if you have definite knowledge that you should at least go to your partner and say 'I have information to add'. Then, let your partner decide. My question is, if the play is going to the hole between the T and the L, why is the Slot seeing it?

Because this is one of crew's crazy game play situations.

You'll get used to them after a while.

[crew]

Originally posted by jpageref
I agree that if you have definite knowledge that you should at least go to your partner and say 'I have information to add'. Then, let your partner decide. My question is, if the play is going to the hole between the T and the L, why is the Slot seeing it?

it is just a scenario i dreamed up. why does any call out of their primary? lack of trust? lack of experience? brain fart? it happens from time to time.

[crew]

this is to:
dan_ref, mick, mark t. denucci, chuckelias, bktballref, and mark dexter.
why specifically would you do as you stated in your post and not try to correct an obvious mistake?

bktballref-"if john has a travel then i have a travel" this statement shows that you respect and trust john clougherty. but wouldnt you offer help if he obviously missed an out of bounds play?

on the other side: jpageref, specifically why would you do as you stated in your post instead of putting the ball in play and moving on?

just curious.......

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by crew
this is to:
dan_ref, mick, mark t. denucci, chuckelias, bktballref, and mark dexter.
why specifically would you do as you stated in your post and not try to correct an obvious mistake?

bktballref-"if john has a travel then i have a travel" this statement shows that you respect and trust john clougherty. but wouldnt you offer help if he obviously missed an out of bounds play?

Remember guys,you will be judged on your answers.TH's personal best is 5.8 to date.Giving the additional incentive involved here,expectations are high that he will surpass that!Points will be added for originality.GO FOR THE GOLD!

[mick]

Originally posted by crew
this is to:
dan_ref, mick, mark t. denucci, chuckelias, bktballref, and mark dexter.
why specifically would you do as you stated in your post and not try to correct an obvious mistake?

"...as he picks up his dribble he takes 2 steps and has the ball low in his mid section with both hands...."

This is a judgement call. I won't question him about any fouls that he had called. I won't question his travel calls.
Hey, crew, maybe I missed something !

[crew]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by mick

This is a judgement call. I won't question him about any fouls that he had called. I won't question his travel calls.
Hey, crew, maybe I missed something !

on this play, lets assume you you have not "missed something".

[mick]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by crew

Originally posted by mick

on this play, lets assume you you have not "missed something".

crew,
As an official, I do not assume I am perfect on any play.
If I were to assume perfection, I wouldn't be me. I may be you!
mick

[mick]

Originally posted by jpageref
I agree that if you have definite knowledge that you should at least go to your partner and say 'I have information to add'. Then, let your partner decide. My question is, if the play is going to the hole between the T and the L, why is the Slot seeing it?

jpageref,
I hate it when it happens, but every now and then, (I call it the parting of the Red Sea) the players pull apart and all of a sudden this perfectly, unalduterated view of a play 25-30' away is way too much to handle by just enjoying the view.
Although I am not sure I've done it in months, seeing that play so clearly makes me go, "Tweet!" ("Dang it!!!!!")
mick

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by mick
crew,
As an official, I do not assume I am perfect on any play.
If I were to assume perfection, I wouldn't be me. I may be you!
mick
[/B]

I like it!The judge from France awards you a 5.9!C'est formidable!

[Edited by Jurassic Referee on Feb 23rd, 2002 at 01:37 PM]

[mick]

Originally posted by Jurassic Referee

I like it!The judge from France awards you a 5.9!C'est formidable!

[Edited by Jurassic Referee on Feb 23rd, 2002 at 01:37 PM] [/B]

JR,
I thought you were at that 117 game 13 gym tourney.
Get back to work.
mick

[mick]

Originally posted by mick

JR,
I thought you were at that 117 game 13 gym tourney.
Get back to work.

Oh, merci, que sera sera. (Cinq point neuf? D'accord.)

mick [/B]

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally posted by mick
JR,
I thought you were at that 117 game 13 gym tourney.
Get back to work.

Oh, merci, que sera sera. (Cinq point neuf? D'accord.)

mick [/B]

[/B][/QUOTE]Yup,the representative of UPper Mesabia is our current leader,and it looks like he will be tough to beat!
Btw,I am working.I answer the damn phone every time it rings.No major screw-ups,YET!