Thought provoking back court question.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

I'm just sitting here, eating my popcorn, while you guys discuss this silly play.

It's simple...if you judge the nthrow a try, it's not a BC violation. If you judge it not to be a try, it's a violation.

You could argue forever whether it's a try or not. No one will win.

I'll buy that. Main reason I posted was that an overwhelming majority seemed to say "IT IS A TRY!" (cuz I said so even) This judgment doesn't seem any tougher to make than countless others we are asked to make every night.