Quote:
Originally posted by Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.
Quote:
Originally posted by cmathews
MTD, well I still don't like the feel of moving the ball up the court, there is no rule or case play to support it, I also agree there is no rule or case play that directly prohibits it either. To me if we put the time back to the original we just do the whole thing over. I don't think that you can definitively say that that is wrong either, because there is no specific case or rule to cite one way or the other...I will give you this, you are consistent in your moving the ball up the court LOL....but as we all know half of this game is 90% mental....
|
You still have not answered my question: Why would you negate A1's throw-in? Tell me how the clock starting too soon negates Team A's throw-in?
|
I would negate the throw-in just as in the play during the game you negated the time on the clock.
If you go with the throw in and let that happen, then you might as well go with the horn sounding and end the game.
Basically you have allowed action to take place during a dead ball. Why let one action (the throw in) happen, but not let the other action (the clock starting) happen.
Thanks
David
Sun Feb 01, 2004, 12:47am
Threaded Mode
