Florida / Texas Tech Denied Substitution

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Raymond

Rewound my DVR to see if the player had been in the game previously and he had not. I think the crew got it wrong. Yes, they were reviewing a timing mistake, but the ball was already dead when they went to review. If they had stopped play to review a timing mistake then the sub would not have been allowed.

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

A pretty big mistake for that point of the game...not allowing a team to have the personnel on the court that they wanted. They had someone in for offense and wanted to put someone in for defense and were denied. I'd be pissed if that were the case...and the coach was.

[Blindolbat]

This is similar to the discussion we had a couple weeks ago about a sub that came in to play defense but then the direction was changed and the coach was not allowed to take the sub back. Some here agreed with that ruling, some did not.
At that point of the game, depending upon which is getting the ball will often determine whether the coach wants the sub.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

... not allowing a team to have the personnel on the court that they wanted.

In my high school games, if I'm not 100% sure that the substitution is illegal, then the substitute is coming in.

My biggest problem regarding substitutions is often my partner, who may not subscribe to my statement above (or who doesn't know the rules).

A few problems this past year involved the timekeeper incorrectly sounding the substitution horn a split second after the ball had already been put at the disposal of the inbounder, or had already been inbounded. In these cases, I will hold my whistle to see if the substitute will hold back so that the play can continue. I've had partners who sound their whistle right away, stopping the play, and resetting the inbound play. I don't have a problem with that (it may prevent the ball handler from "double dribbling"), I do have a problem when they followup by denying the substitution. The ball is dead and the clock is stopped, one can't deny a substitution (assuming the substitute is otherwise eligible, sit a tick, not disqualified, proper uniform and equipment, no blood, etc.) in that situation.