Shooting foul at end of period

[Altor]

What I saw and heard from the stands, in order. This all happened bang, bang, bang, bang:

W44 grabs B23 on the arm as he begins his shot near the block. L blows his whistle. The buzzer sounds. B23 releases the shot which goes in the basket. Clock does not display tenths of a second.

Do you (a) count the goal and give B23 a FT with the lane cleared? (b) count the goal, use "definite knowledge" to put a second back on the clock and resume play with the FT? Or (c) waive off the goal and have B23 shoot two FTs with the lane empty?

[Rich]

C


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[crosscountry55]

C. Foul or not, you still have to release the try before time expires. Sure, in theory the clock should stop before the release, but in NFHS, with neither PTS nor replay, there is a human response allowance for the timer to react. That said, foul on an unsuccessful try (assuming the foul was before the expiration of time) results in two (or three) free throws.

If—and this is a big if—somehow an official had definite knowledge of what the precise time was at the whistle, I suppose the official could count the basket, put the correct time back up, and shoot one with lane spaces occupied. Without that definite knowledge, you’d be guessing with respect to putting time back up. Don’t go there (apologies in advance to the 0.3ers out there, but there is no NFHS rules or case support for that). Be comfortable that you knew the release was late, honor the timer allowance, clear the lane, and shoot two.

NCAA w/ monitor = use it to determine all that you need to determine. With monitor, the only time you’d ever shoot throws in this scenario with the lane cleared is if there was a release, followed by time expiring, and then a foul on the airborne shooter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

If somehow an official had definite knowledge of what the precise time was at the whistle, I suppose the official could count the basket, put the correct time back up, and shoot one with lane spaces occupied.

Like one of the officials observing 0.9 seconds on the game clock when the whistle was sounded? That's not guessing. Right?

[crosscountry55]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Like one of the officials observing 0.9 seconds on the game clock when the whistle was sounded? That's not guessing. Right?

Correct. Definite knowledge. Put 0.9 up and carry on.

As a non-calling official I want to and try to look up at the clock as soon as I hear a whistle. But I’ve had to train my brain to do this. It’s not instinctive, and I still don’t always do it, especially if there’s dead ball shenanigans going on or likely to occur.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

NCAA w/ monitor = use it to determine all that you need to determine. With monitor, the only time you’d ever shoot throws in this scenario with the lane cleared is if there was a release, followed by time expiring, and then a foul on the airborne shooter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Do you know, in this scenario do they look at the time the foul occurred, or when the official called the foul? A drive through the lane with marginal contact could be difficult to determine when a foul actually occurred, but an official with a patient whistle would obviously react after the foul should have been called.

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by frezer11

Do you know, in this scenario do they look at the time the foul occurred, or when the official called the foul? A drive through the lane with marginal contact could be difficult to determine when a foul actually occurred, but an official with a patient whistle would obviously react after the foul should have been called.

In writing that, I think I answered my own question, but lets focus on that first part, how can you determine when the foul actually occurred, especially on a call in which there is marginal contact during the drive and attempt?

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by frezer11

... do they look at the time the foul occurred, or when the official called the foul?

High school, no monitor:

NFHS 5-8-1-A: Time-out occurs and the clock, if running, shall be stopped when an official: Signals: A foul.

The foul doesn't stop the clock, the signal (simultaneous fist/stop clock signal) stops the clock.

[Nevadaref]

Originally Posted by frezer11

Do you know, in this scenario do they look at the time the foul occurred, or when the official called the foul? A drive through the lane with marginal contact could be difficult to determine when a foul actually occurred, but an official with a patient whistle would obviously react after the foul should have been called.

The NCAA rule is to restore the time at which the illegal contact occurred. The calling official would look at the video and determine the point at which he believed the foul took place. That is the moment at which the game clock would be halted.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by frezer11

Do you know, in this scenario do they look at the time the foul occurred, or when the official called the foul? A drive through the lane with marginal contact could be difficult to determine when a foul actually occurred, but an official with a patient whistle would obviously react after the foul should have been called.

NCAAW: By definition, it's when the whistle is blown that matters.

[bucky]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

High school, no monitor:

NFHS 5-8-1-A: Time-out occurs and the clock, if running, shall be stopped when an official: Signals: A foul.

The foul doesn't stop the clock, the signal (simultaneous fist/stop clock signal) stops the clock.

What is the point of blowing the whistle? (stay with me on this) Where in the rule book is it a required action with regards to fouls and violations? Is it in the manual perhaps?

[HokiePaul]

Has their been a case play on this before? It seems familiar, but maybe it's been discussed here before.

The reason I ask is I'm wondering what the justification is for not counting the basket? I understand not being able to add time without knowledge, but why is the shooter not allowed continuous motion in this instance?

There is the rule stating that whether the clock is running or is stopped has no influence on the counting of a goal. And you know that the foul occurred prior to the expiration of time (whistle was before the horn). What is the rules/case reference to treat this different than the usual determination of whether or not the player had begun the trying or tapping movement?

Edit:
"A live-ball foul by the offense (team in control or last in control if the ball is loose), or the expiration of time for a quarter or extra period, causes the ball to become dead immediately, unless the ball is in flight during a try or tap for goal. The ball also becomes dead when a player-control foul occurs."

I'm guessing this is the rules justification, but if you know the foul occurred prior to the expiration of time, then I think you have a strong argument that this doesn't apply.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by HokiePaul

Has their been a case play on this before? It seems familiar, but maybe it's been discussed here before.

You can get some of it from 5.6.2D (last year's reference).

There have been other cases that contain more detail -- the point is that unless an official sees the time remaining, then the timer is allowed some "normal reaction time*" to stop the clock, so the time is allowed to expire in the OP.

If there is replay (as in NCAA), then you can go back and add time -- we can't arbitrarily add time in HS (nor in NCAA (at least NCAAW) when there is no monitor

* -- I am not sure if that phrase still exists in the books or not (it used to be limited to 1 second, but I know that part was removed -- the concept still applies unless an official has definite knowledge of the time)

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by bucky

What is the point of blowing the whistle? (stay with me on this) Where in the rule book is it a required action with regards to fouls and violations? Is it in the manual perhaps?

Rulebook? Doesn't mention whistles.

IAABO Manual: Sound whistle simultaneously with the foul signal.