Shooting vs. passing after foul

[BigCat]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I am not being hard headed. I have been doing this long enough to make a judgment one way or the other. I think the video is not terribly helpful as I have evaluated many officials, only to have them give me more information by what they say when you ask them about the play. I even said I do not care what you do in this play. You will have to live with your call, just as I will have to do the same.

Peace

I'm not worried about me or you. I just want any younger official who sees this to realize it's clearly a shooting foul. Not even close. They can choose to believe you or me. That is up to them.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by BigCat

I'm not worried about me or you. I just want any younger official who sees this to realize it's clearly a shooting foul. Not even close. They can choose to believe you or me. That is up to them.

That is great, but if I showed this to a room full of officials, you would have a lot of different opinions. I know it, because I show video all the time like this and you get all kinds of opinions. So you can in your noble way try to tell people what to think, there will be someone that tells them to do it another way. Now that is a fact. It is a fact becasue rarely do I have a video like this that is not have a debate on a close play. And on this site people have stated it is not that "obvious."

Peace

[BigCat]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

That is great, but if I showed this to a room full of officials, you would have a lot of different opinions. I know it, because I show video all the time like this and you get all kinds of opinions. So you can in your noble way try to tell people what to think, there will be someone that tells them to do it another way. Now that is a fact. It is a fact becasue rarely do I have a video like this that is not have a debate on a close play. And on this site people have stated it is not that "obvious."

Peace

No, I really don't think there'd be a lot of different opinions. I've been wrong before but this isn't that close.

[APG]

No shot on either of the plays...

And yes I would absolutely come in with information. It's on my partner if he/she wants to use it or not.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by BigCat

No, I really don't think there'd be a lot of different opinions. I've been wrong before but this isn't that close.

You must not have done many presentations with video?

Peace