RHP Pick off attempt to first. Balk?

[Rita C]

Whenever I first introduce the concept to coaches that the pitcher can, indeed, throw to first without disengaging, the first question they invariably ask is, "Are you saying he can just turn and throw?"

They ask the question while demonstrating the move you describe which is an awkward move.

My answer? Yes he can.

Rita

[Rufus]

I remember getting into a heated discussion with a fellow coach about this very thing a few years ago. He insisted that RH pitchers can't do what the OP described.

To settle the argument I asked if it's legal for LH pitchers to make the move. He answered "Of course." I responded with "So you're telling me there's a separate section in the rules for RH vs. LH pitchers?" Deer in headlights.

All that being said, I wouldn't coach a RH pitcher to do this precisely because there is so much confusion over it and it's just as effective, if not more so, to teach RH pitchers a more "traditional" pick-off move.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by Rita C

Whenever I first introduce the concept to coaches that the pitcher can, indeed, throw to first without disengaging, the first question they invariably ask is, "Are you saying he can just turn and throw?"

They ask the question while demonstrating the move you describe which is an awkward move.

My answer? Yes he can.

Rita

As long as we have a step to the base before the throw.

[Steven Tyler]

Or more commonly called, gain ground and distance.............

[Rita C]

Originally Posted by mbyron

As long as we have a step to the base before the throw.

The move, as I envision it, includes a step. An awkward one but it is a step.

So there.

Rita