Dale Scott calls a ball foul then fair

[RadioBlue]

Originally Posted by Tim C

Not true my good man, not true.

T

Perhaps you're right at the college or pro level. Since I don't work those levels, I won't dispute what you're saying. I can tell you that it is a "dead ball" (as well as "time" and "foul") signal at the NFHS level.



But my point remains the same, if you've signaled it, you've called it.

[David B]

Originally Posted by RadioBlue

Perhaps you're right at the college or pro level. Since I don't work those levels, I won't dispute what you're saying. I can tell you that it is a "dead ball" (as well as "time" and "foul") signal at the NFHS level.



But my point remains the same, if you've signaled it, you've called it.

Not true. Was looking in my BRD and at the NFHS level there is a whole section on reversing a call etc.,

That is also why they added the rule a couple years ago about what happens now when the umpire does verbalize "foul" etc.,

I'm not agreeing he did everything wrong, but I am saying I've had similiar plays happen and sometimes you just have to umpire.

But its obviously NOT cut and dry that just because you throw your arms out that you have a dead ball.

thanks
David

[jwwashburn]

That guy has ENORMOUS hands.

[yawetag]

Originally Posted by jwwashburn

That guy has ENORMOUS hands.

Maybe his hands are "normal" sized; it's just the rest of his body that's small.

[briancurtin]

Originally Posted by jwwashburn

That guy has ENORMOUS hands.

You know what they say about umpires with big hands?

[BestUmp]

Originally Posted by briancurtin

You know what they say about umpires with big hands?

They need large indicators! Good one, briancurtin!

[Rich]

Originally Posted by jwwashburn

That guy has ENORMOUS hands.

And apparently has a gun in his back. Another tell-tale sign of a Smitty -- throws his hands up over his head like he's being held up when calling "TIME" (or more than likely "DEAD BALL").

[BestUmp]

Originally Posted by GROUPthink

And apparently has a gun in his back. Another tell-tale sign of a Smitty -- throws his hands up over his head like he's being held up when calling "TIME" (or more than likely "DEAD BALL").

It's a drawing! Be reasonable, troll elsewhere!

[Rich]

Originally Posted by BestUmp

It's a drawing! Be reasonable, troll elsewhere!

Easy for you to say, FitUmp. And my ignore lists grows larger.

[BestUmp]

Originally Posted by GROUPthink

Easy for you to say, FitUmp. And my ignore lists grows larger.

Thank you for the correction, although I fail to pay any attention to it at all!

Let's be friends, both of us just joined the gruppe recently!