Place the Runners

[yawetag]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

R2 would get home.

+1. There's no such this as "1+1" in awarding bases. For throws going out of play, it's a two base award. If the throw is the first play by an infielder, the bases are awarded from their base at the time of the pitch. If the throw is by an outfielder or a subsequent play by an infielder, it's two bases from the time of the throw.

[rbmartin]

This happened yesterday in the Reds/Brewers game and was handled correctly (of course) by the umps.

Baseball Video Highlights & Clips | CIN@MIL: Lucroy scores on an error by Janish - Video | MLB.com: Multimedia

[Rich]

Originally Posted by rbmartin

This happened yesterday in the Reds/Brewers game and was handled correctly (of course) by the umps.

Baseball Video Highlights & Clips | CIN@MIL: Lucroy scores on an error by Janish - Video | MLB.com: Multimedia

After a long delay. The announcer was cut off (in the clip), but it's obvious he was about to make an incredibly wrong statement.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

After a long delay. The announcer was cut off (in the clip), but it's obvious he was about to make an incredibly wrong statement.

The PbP guy managed to get in a helpful "2 from the field."

I didn't notice that the play started with R2. No idea why that runner stopped at 3B, as I'm sure he was told, "you, score!"

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by mbyron

I didn't notice that the play started with R2. No idea why that runner stopped at 3B, as I'm sure he was told, "you, score!"

No no no...didn't you hear the common tater? R2 was initially told to go to third and then he was later sent home. If a talking head said it, then it must be true.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by Welpe

No no no...didn't you hear the common tater? R2 was initially told to go to third and then he was later sent home. If a talking head said it, then it must be true.

Yeah, I'm astonished that the conference happened so fast that the cameras didn't catch it.

[yawetag]

Originally Posted by rbmartin

This happened yesterday in the Reds/Brewers game and was handled correctly (of course) by the umps.

Baseball Video Highlights & Clips | CIN@MIL: Lucroy scores on an error by Janish - Video | MLB.com: Multimedia

I'm not convinced they initially got it right. The runner may have stopped at third after being awarded home, but I'm not 100% convinced. There's nothing showing the umpire awarding bases.

[rbmartin]

Originally Posted by yawetag

I'm not convinced they initially got it right. The runner may have stopped at third after being awarded home, but I'm not 100% convinced. There's nothing showing the umpire awarding bases.

The good thing about a dead ball is you have plenty of time to get it right.

[DG]

Did not see a conference and don't know why one would be necessary. I did have a similar situation once in a tournament game, I was working U3 position. Similar in that F4 bobbled the ball and then threw it over F2's head out of play and runner from 1b was being scored. Ball was already dead so I called crew together for discussion. One item of discussion was that the fielder bobbled the ball and then threw it out of play so the throw was 2nd play play by an infielder. I said bobbling the ball and picking it up was not a play it was screwup, throwing the ball was a play, and we all agreed on that and runner R1 returned to 3b. He had reached 2b at TOT if anyone wondering.

Can't see a major league crew needing this discussion.

[Rich]

Do you ever see a ML crew aggressively awarding bases? In the games I attend where balls are thrown in the stands, it seems like they don't really do much of anything and just assume that runners know where to go.

I know in a HS game, I *must* say "you, score" loud enough for everyone to hear and decisively enough to avoid having a visit.

[MikeStrybel]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Do you ever see a ML crew aggressively awarding bases? In the games I attend where balls are thrown in the stands, it seems like they don't really do much of anything and just assume that runners know where to go.

I know in a HS game, I *must* say "you, score" loud enough for everyone to hear and decisively enough to avoid having a visit.

At the Chicago NCAA meetings they showed a couple MLB plays for obstruction. In both, the umpires were emphatic and immediate in their awards. Even in the bigs, players don't always know where to go on such calls. Tom also showed two NCAA plays involving obstruction - both types. One involved a runner believing that he was protected when in fact he wasn't. Hiler reiterated the need for umpires to be assertive on this call and reminded us that collegiate athletes (in this case D-1) typically aren't aware of the award.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by DG

Did not see a conference and don't know why one would be necessary. I did have a similar situation once in a tournament game, I was working U3 position. Similar in that F4 bobbled the ball and then threw it over F2's head out of play and runner from 1b was being scored. Ball was already dead so I called crew together for discussion. One item of discussion was that the fielder bobbled the ball and then threw it out of play so the throw was 2nd play play by an infielder. I said bobbling the ball and picking it up was not a play it was screwup, throwing the ball was a play, and we all agreed on that and runner R1 returned to 3b. He had reached 2b at TOT if anyone wondering.

Can't see a major league crew needing this discussion.

Catching a ball (grounder, line drive, popup) is never a play. I wonder why so many umpires have a problem with this concept.

[yawetag]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Catching a ball (grounder, line drive, popup) is never a play. I wonder why so many umpires have a problem with this concept.

If it were a play, there would be no reason for the rule, as all throws would be a subsequent play.