Let's take a trip..

[kylejt]

Eject the coach fo sure.

Players? Depends on their age. Little guys? Naw. They're just following orders from an idiot adult.

Now if you had R1 at third, and R2 at second, THEN you've got an out, when you put it in play. Hey, sometimes you've got to be creative to get outs when coaches try this stuff. This may just be how you remembered it, before the ball was hit.

Yup, R1 passed R2, as soon as the ball was put in play. R1 is out, score R2, eject the coach, and anyone else who wishes to argue with you about it.

That would be fun.