Rumor has it . . .

[Umpmazza]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

That's already allowed (with a RH batter). They won't change it with a LH batter unless they also change the "half swing" mechanic to go to the person on the line.

in the CCA it was a change this year..U1 no is the umpire who decides/ make the decision if he goes out..the reason is U3 is already coming, so If U1 goes out, you still have a umpire in front.. CCA adopted it this year.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by Umpmazza

in the CCA it was a change this year..U1 no is the umpire who decides/ make the decision if he goes out..the reason is U3 is already coming, so If U1 goes out, you still have a umpire in front.. CCA adopted it this year.

This is the way we've (locally) *always* done 3-person. U3 can always adjust and read off the U1 -- if the U1 goes out, U3 comes up. If the U1 starts in, the U3 can adjust and go out. It doesn't work the other way.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Umpmazza

in the CCA it was a change this year..U1 no is the umpire who decides/ make the decision if he goes out..the reason is U3 is already coming, so If U1 goes out, you still have a umpire in front.. CCA adopted it this year.

The change you mention (who is the "quarterback") is a change this year. I agree.

That's not what was being discussed in the conversation you quoted -- that conversation had to do with U3's positioning with R1 only.

(to be fair, I quoted both parts of a previous post, even though I only responded to the second part. I could have been more clear.)