Continuous action?

PeteBooth · #7 (**permalink**) Tue Nov 03, 2009, 12:09pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jkumpire

You are the PU on this play, what do you call?

Without the benefit of hindsight or replay?

I am very tempted to call him safe anyway, but his arm and body is high enough over the plate a she goes over that I think I could see it. I'd call him out, and then eject about 3 guys who would argue the call.

However, a long time ago, there was a discussion about this on a list serve of umpires put together by Mr. Childress, that Tee and several others on this board were a part of.

As I remember the conversation, there was a consensus that if it is close, with very little space between the runner's arm or body and the plate, call him safe.

Comments?

You are the PU on this play, what do you call?

I call what I see. It's apparent from the replay that the PU did not SEE Howard touch home either OTHERWISE he would have signalled safe right away. It wasn't until Posada threw the ball that the PU gave a casual safe signal. I doubt you learn that kind of a safe signal in PRO school. It looked more like a first year LL umpire safe signal.

On a tag attempt at the plate where the runner misses the plate and the fielder misses the tag there is a NO call to make. At first that is EXACTLY what the PU did. He gave NO signal.

If you want to rule safe then SIGNAL safe 'right away". That is not what the home plate umpire did. The PU did not signal safe UNTIL Posada threw the ball to second base.

It would have been interesting to see what would have happend had the Yanks appealed the play.

Pete Booth

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Continuous Motion	RookieDude	Basketball	16	Mon Dec 18, 2006 07:59pm
"Continuous Action"?	Yeggman	Softball	6	Wed Dec 14, 2005 08:52am
Continuous motion	Paul LeBoutillier	Basketball	3	Mon Feb 28, 2005 02:22pm
Continuous motion	Bizket786	Basketball	5	Fri Dec 10, 2004 04:10pm
Continuous Motion	ronny mulkey	Basketball	20	Sun Dec 28, 2003 03:01pm