Video posted on the NFHS Discussion Forum.

[MrUmpire]

Originally Posted by Bishopcolle

Disagree....As a parent,

There's the problem. You're thinking like a parent, whereas we understand how to perform like an umpire.

Nothing good can come from physically getting involved. Our job is, to the best of our ability, record the violators.

[Bishopcolle]

Originally Posted by MrUmpire

There's the problem. You're thinking like a parent, whereas we understand how to perform like an umpire.

Nothing good can come from physically getting involved. Our job is, to the best of our ability, record the violators.

Well, I can't disagree with you all...but I am NOT thinking as a parent, and that's my problem...I'm thinking as a 32-year cop....trying to establish some order without hands on (I agree with that), but you're right....too much cop trying to establish order...better to back off and sort it out long distance....
Whew! That's hard for me to do.....

[Matt]

Originally Posted by Bishopcolle

I'm thinking as a 32-year cop

I'm not so sure that's why you thought you did...because I know I didn't have the same thought as you. I think you were probably thinking as a parent, as you initially stated.

[Welpe]

After a quick search, I now remember reading this thread in the basketball forum. Fight scenario

Is it no longer correct to eject players leaving the bench that do not participate?

Edit: Never mind, you snuck a reply in on me while I was still writing mine.

Sorry for discussing basketball and football here, but I think it is worth exploring to see if the Fed has similar thinking in similar situations in other sports.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by Welpe

Sorry for discussing basketball and football here, but I think it is worth exploring to see if the Fed has similar thinking in similar situations in other sports.

In general, trying to compare sports is a mistake. Remember that "FED" is a committee of committees. There is no expectation of consistency across every sport, except at the most abstract level (every sport emphasizes "safety," for example, but that means something very different in volleyball and football).

The rules committees for different sports do not get together and consult about whether everyone who leaves the bench during a fight is ejected.

[Bishopcolle]

Originally Posted by Matt

I'm not so sure that's why you thought you did...because I know I didn't have the same thought as you. I think you were probably thinking as a parent, as you initially stated.

wrong

[JR12]

[QUOTE=Bishopcolle;603720]Well, I can't disagree with you all...but I am NOT thinking as a parent, and that's my problem...I'm thinking as a 32-year cop....trying to establish some order without hands on (I agree with that), but you're right....too much cop trying to establish order...better to back off and sort it out long distance....
Whew! That's hard for me to do.....[/QUOTE

I'm a cop too, however my dept says off duty the only REQUIREMENT is to call 911.If I decide to take action I run the risk of civil liability and a possible IA complaint. Also I rarely do games in the jurisdiction I work. Therefore if I would write down numbers, don't touch anyone, ensure the ON DUTY Police are called, make ejections, be a good witness, That way I make my assoc. and department happy!
Old motto from an old timer cop. "If you put your hands on someone, lock them up"!

[Bishopcolle]

[QUOTE=JR12;603772]

Originally Posted by Bishopcolle

Well, I can't disagree with you all...but I am NOT thinking as a parent, and that's my problem...I'm thinking as a 32-year cop....trying to establish some order without hands on (I agree with that), but you're right....too much cop trying to establish order...better to back off and sort it out long distance....
Whew! That's hard for me to do.....[/QUOTE

I'm a cop too, however my dept says off duty the only REQUIREMENT is to call 911.If I decide to take action I run the risk of civil liability and a possible IA complaint. Also I rarely do games in the jurisdiction I work. Therefore if I would write down numbers, don't touch anyone, ensure the ON DUTY Police are called, make ejections, be a good witness, That way I make my assoc. and department happy!
Old motto from an old timer cop. "If you put your hands on someone, lock them up"!

I agree....just indicated that it's hard to shut down certain feelings and trainings....From one Blue to another....

[ozzy6900]

Originally Posted by Bishopcolle

Well, I can't disagree with you all...but I am NOT thinking as a parent, and that's my problem...I'm thinking as a 32-year cop....trying to establish some order without hands on (I agree with that), but you're right....too much cop trying to establish order...better to back off and sort it out long distance....
Whew! That's hard for me to do.....

It's easy! You're hang-up is your badge! That is what allows you do become "involved" in an altercation. Umpires are officials but not police. We cannot become involved with the altercation once it starts. We can try and prevent it, but once it starts, the law is not with us if we get involved.

Example: Police officer grabs Player1 by the arm and Player2 punches Player1 in the face breaking his jaw. The officer is not sued for holding the arm of Player1. We as sports officials would be.

[umpjong]

I always found that pulling my off duty weapon out of my spare ball bag and firing a warning shot was very effective.... (at least it worked for me )

[Ump Rube]

I didn't realize that Galco made holster/ball-bags. Can you post a review when you have spare couple of minutes.

[socalblue1]

Originally Posted by umpjong

I always found that pulling my off duty weapon out of my spare ball bag and firing a warning shot was very effective.... (at least it worked for me )

Flash bangs are even better.

[bfoster]

Did everyone notice that the catcher actually slammed his hockey-style catcher's mask into the runner on the ground? What a goon.

[Bishopcolle]

Originally Posted by ozzy6900

It's easy! You're hang-up is your badge! That is what allows you do become "involved" in an altercation. Umpires are officials but not police. We cannot become involved with the altercation once it starts. We can try and prevent it, but once it starts, the law is not with us if we get involved.

Example: Police officer grabs Player1 by the arm and Player2 punches Player1 in the face breaking his jaw. The officer is not sued for holding the arm of Player1. We as sports officials would be.

Well said....good points....

[spokanelurker]

As a coach with whom several of you often disagree, here's my take. One of my kids asked me in jest this year, "Coach, what would you do if we brawl?" My answer was clear and not in jest: "I'd pull all of you off the field and we'd forfeit." Don't care what rule's cited, or what might start it, we'd be done, and it wouldn't take an umpire to make the decision for me.