What is the outcome of this?

[UmpJM]

Originally Posted by JPaco54

Bob - I am confused now as to what the proper call would be with the one out scenario. Is this a timing situation? Back to the OP, If appeal made, R1 is out for the second out for missing 2B. R3 scores and R2 scores. BR if advanced to second on the throw to third would maintain 2B. Correct?

But if 2 outs, it becomes a "force" situation and no runs score? Appreciate clarification. Thanks!

JPaco,

I'm not Bob, but let me try to answer your question..

If there is only one out at the start of the play, there is no "timing" to concern yourself with because at the end of the play there are only two outs - even if the defense were to appeal the R1's miss of 2B.

Since they already put him out when he tried to advance to 3B, he's really, really out, but it's still just one out.

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

but it's an appeal play, not a force play right?

johnny,

You seem to suggest these are mutually exclusive options - they are not. See post #5 above.

JM