Navy OC Shirts - Different Shades?

[Blue37]

I recently received four shirts from Officials Choice. Two of them were navy and are different sizes - one to wear behind the plate and one for the bases. The workmanship of the shirts are fine and I like the feel of the fabric, but they are noticeably different in shade. The 2X is so dark as to appear black. The other two shirts are powder blue and are also different sizes, but the shades of those shirts are identical.

Anyone else received an OC shirt that is a darker shade of navy?

[ozzy6900]

Just as an observation, this is the exact reason why I only buy Cliff Keen shirts.

[cardinalfan]

Originally Posted by Blue37

I recently received four shirts from Officials Choice. Two of them were navy and are different sizes - one to wear behind the plate and one for the bases. The workmanship of the shirts are fine and I like the feel of the fabric, but they are noticeably different in shade. The 2X is so dark as to appear black. The other two shirts are powder blue and are also different sizes, but the shades of those shirts are identical.

Anyone else received an OC shirt that is a darker shade of navy?

My OC navy seems a little darker than my Honigs navy, but not enough to matter.
If it is really noticeable, I would give them a call. If they want to be a player in this game, customer service will be one of the keys.

[cardinalfan]

Originally Posted by ozzy6900

Just as an observation, this is the exact reason why I only buy Cliff Keen shirts.

I agree.
I did get a bad Cliff Keen shirt for basketball this year, however. The seam between the arm and shoulder decided not to be a team player after just a few times through the washing machine.

[BretMan]

My knocks on the OC shirts (already documented in a previous thread):

- The material is too sheer- almost like "see-through" sheer. You'll have to give some thought to what undershirt you wear, because any logo or printing will be easily read right through the OC shirt. Any logos, pads, buckles or straps on your chest protector will be fairly visible.

- The powder blue shirt I got from OC had light blue buttons. After less than half a season- maybe 6-8 wearings and washes- the buttons faded to a hideous pinkish-purplely color. I replaced them myself.

- The only issues I had with wear and tear or their construction was the stitching around a couple of of the button holes unraveled a bit.

Other than that, I haven't had any problems. If those are things that you can live with you should be happy with the shirts. They are lightweight, comfortable and relatively cool. And, the shirts are generously sized- the Large fits me close to an Extra-Large from other makers.

[Kevin Finnerty]

Other than the odd sizing, color shade inconsistencies, fabric inconsistencies, non-standard trim styles, discolored buttons, occasionally over-sized shirt pockets, out-of-stock product, amateurish marketing and arrogant management, Official's Choice is a fine company.

[johnnyg08]

I've only dealt with them on a couple of shirts...honestly, I don't think I'll go with them again only because I want some consistency with sizes and appearance...most of my partners wear Honigs, so it only makes sense to go that direction.

On another note, am I missing something with one version of the light blue shirt? Did the red/white/blue collar get replaced by the navy/powdered blue collar...(those two are used when my partner doesn't have the black collar) I'm just seeing fewer and fewer red/white/blue collar and more of what used to be the "softball" version.

[Kevin Finnerty]

Red, white and blue collar: College
White and navy collar: High School Baseball and Softball

[johnnyg08]

Got it.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

I've only dealt with them on a couple of shirts...honestly, I don't think I'll go with them again only because I want some consistency with sizes and appearance...most of my partners wear Honigs, so it only makes sense to go that direction.

On another note, am I missing something with one version of the light blue shirt? Did the red/white/blue collar get replaced by the navy/powdered blue collar...(those two are used when my partner doesn't have the black collar) I'm just seeing fewer and fewer red/white/blue collar and more of what used to be the "softball" version.

I'm sure it varies by area.

No one around here has worn the red-white-blue collar for many years, and the navy collar is now (in the past couple of years) also out for baseball (replaced by the polo blue shirt with the black collar).

[johnnyg08]

I like the black collar as well. I'd like to start our assn toward that version. it's hard enough to get guys to upgrade to unfaded stuff...but that would be nice. i can see the other side too in the fact that there appears to be a new shirt every few years.

[Kevin Finnerty]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

I'm sure it varies by area.

No one around here has worn the red-white-blue collar for many years, and the navy collar is now (in the past couple of years) also out for baseball (replaced by the polo blue shirt with the black collar).

Keep saying it and maybe the "powder" will disappear completely!

I feel like a softball-umping retiree when I am forced to wear the powder. I get 15 years older just putting it on.

The MLB "polo" is easily acceptable.

[Welpe]

Originally Posted by Kevin Finnerty

Red, white and blue collar: College

Also an approved color for use by TASO umpires.

[Kevin Finnerty]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

I like the black collar as well. I'd like to start our assn toward that version. it's hard enough to get guys to upgrade to unfaded stuff...but that would be nice. i can see the other side too in the fact that there appears to be a new shirt every few years.

The main units in Los Angeles have officially okay'd the use of any of the main colors (navy, powder, polo, black, cream, gray, white) as long as the umpires match. I guess this is how it should be.

I would wear black at every opportunity. But when the temperature hits 80, it gets tough. Gray, cream and MLB blue all make nice alternates. I have two of every color and am always willing to let my partner borrow any shirt that fits, so he can try a new alternate color, and so we don't have to wear the powder.

Heather and powder ... I don't even like the words.

[Kevin Finnerty]

Originally Posted by Welpe

Also an approved color for use by TASO umpires.

Gotcha'