Summer rules philosophy

[bossman72]

Guys,

For #1, the J/R suggests a penalty similar to FED rules which contradict Evan's interp. Which do you think should be followed?

[DG]

Originally Posted by bossman72

Guys,

For #1, the J/R suggests a penalty similar to FED rules which contradict Evan's interp. Which do you think should be followed?

Explain.

J/R says illegal sub is ejected when discovered, "however, play is otherwise unnafected and another player takes the place of the ejeced illegal substitute".

[bossman72]

Originally Posted by DG

Explain.

J/R says illegal sub is ejected when discovered, "however, play is otherwise unnafected and another player takes the place of the ejeced illegal substitute".

JR says to rectify any action made by an illegal sub (similar to batting out of order).

Evans says to eject the illegal sub and everything he did would stand.