Another Balk Question

[Fan10]

Originally Posted by UmpJM (nee CoachJM)

As a matter of fact, I believe there are only 3 situations under OBR rules where a manager can choose the result of the play or the penalty. As Rich says, a balk ain't one of them, while Catcher's Interference MAY be one, depending on the result of the play.

JM

Let me see if I can do this:

1. Catcher's interference and a play follows where the batter does not reach first and all runners don't advance at least one base

2. Pitcher doctors ball and a play follows where the batter does not reach first and all runners don't advance at least one base

3. The fourth out where an appeal play is made on a play where the third out is made and the coach has the option of taking the out that gives them the bigger advantage.

How did I do?