Calling what you see or what they see

[Emperor Ump]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Sit #1:

First thing you should always take your time on a play like this and let the players tell you what happen or give an indication of what happen. If the player is not selling that they got hit, then it is easy. If the batter does not give you a clear indication, then you have to make a decision. I think if you waited you would not have sent the batter to first.

Sit #2:

IMO this is an obvious call. You were hit and the fielder clearly misplayed the ball. Who cares what the offense says at that point, but you probably should be quick to make that call. All I can say after that is try not to get hit. That is sometimes easier said than done, but it is not very common.

Peace

Great reply. I've had several HBP situations where I wasn't 100% sure. I made my best decision which was based on what I saw/heard and read the batter, if they agree then its easy. If they don't agree ... thats what we get paid for ... to make the tough decisions.

My only addition would be call what you see thats what you're out there for. You are the trained 'professional' on the field. But also don't go looking for things to call which don't necessarily need to be.

A perfect example of that would be a pitcher with a white Nike TPX or other logo on his glove. I've never seen one , Until the other coach brings it up. Oh, your right coach, I'm sorry I didn't notice that."