3 Mechanics Question

[ManInBlue]

Originally Posted by GarthB

No, it's not. I think you have the "set-up" confused.

You or your memory are mistaken.

You have probably hit the proverbial nail on the head. My set-up could very well be off, and my memory could very well be incorrect. Actually, it's most likely a combination of both.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by ManInBlue

No, not specifically. Although some do use it. I got it from Paul Nauert (sp?), Jerry Crawford, and Brian Reiley (sp?). I've also read it, I believe, but don't recall off the top of my head where.

When was the last time any of these guys worked two-man mechanics?

[GarthB]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

When was the last time any of these guys worked two-man mechanics?

There's a good chance I'll have contact with at least one of those umpires in the next month or so. I'll certainly inquire into why they taught this mechanic.

[bossman72]

Originally Posted by GarthB

There's a good chance I'll have contact with at least one of those umpires in the next month or so. I'll certainly inquire into why they taught this mechanic.

Good thing you mentioned that the PU only gets R2 at third "if he tags" only if there is an R1... I've been covering when there is an R2 only. Time to fix that!!

Once again, Garth makes me a better umpire, little by little. haha

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by bossman72

Good thing you mentioned that the PU only gets R2 at third "if he tags" only if there is an R1... I've been covering when there is an R2 only. Time to fix that!!

Once again, Garth makes me a better umpire, little by little. haha

What, am I on your Ignore List? It seems I said the same thing just before Garth did.

Throw me a frickin' bone, people.

[Publius]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

When was the last time any of these guys worked two-man mechanics?

Brian Reilly worked some 2-man at least as recently as 2006. I'd bet the farm, though, that any reference he may have made to what maninblue described was a response to some third-world situation.

[Don Mueller]

Originally Posted by bossman72

Good thing you mentioned that the PU only gets R2 at third "if he tags" only if there is an R1... I've been covering when there is an R2 only. Time to fix that!!

Once again, Garth makes me a better umpire, little by little. haha

Yes Garth is a great resource! (edited) As is SDS
But what flaws do you have on other basic mechanics?
It may be a long time before the Garth compilation of posts includes all 2 man mechanics. It may be time to read a book.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by Publius

Brian Reilly worked some 2-man at least as recently as 2006. I'd bet the farm, though, that any reference he may have made to what maninblue described was a response to some third-world situation.

I'll admit I don't know Brian Reilly from Charles Nelson Reilly.

[GarthB]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

I'll admit I don't know Brian Reilly from Charles Nelson Reilly.

Brian isn't dead.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by GarthB

Brian isn't dead.

Oh, that's the difference.

[ManInBlue]

Steve - Brian is Mike Reilly's nephew. He's in his 2nd (or 3rd) year at AAA and is an instructor at Harry's.

Garth - Please ask them about it and get back to me with the response. I'd be very curious to see how much of it I've got screwed up.

I'm pretty confident about PU covering 3B. I am now questioning my comments about BU going home.

[ManInBlue]

Originally Posted by Publius

Brian Reilly worked some 2-man at least as recently as 2006. I'd bet the farm, though, that any reference he may have made to what maninblue described was a response to some third-world situation.

Sorry for the double post - I could remember who had posted this...

Anyway - Paul did fungos on the field with us and stressed PU getting to 3B when he could.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by ManInBlue

Sorry for the double post - I could remember who had posted this...

Anyway - Paul did fungos on the field with us and stressed PU getting to 3B when he could.

I would be surprised if he didn't mean to get to 3rd when you are supposed to get there. Like "get there when you can on plays you are supposed to cover third," or words to that effect.

[bobbybanaduck]

tried to send a non-flaming PM rather than post for the world to see, but it would not allow it.

the post you have up there about 2 man mechanics is just about entirely incorrect, some of which you've accepted, and some of which you refuse to. whether you misunderstood brian, or brian messed up in his teaching is moot. though i've never been to harry's, they teach the same thing that jimmy's does, and i've been to jimmy's for a bunch of years in a row now (no, not for my varsity letterman jacket.) both schools teach out of the red book, and the red book says PU covers on a tag up only with R1 and R2, and not with R2 only.

[GarthB]

Originally Posted by bobbybanaduck

tried to send a non-flaming PM rather than post for the world to see, but it would not allow it.

the post you have up there about 2 man mechanics is just about entirely incorrect, some of which you've accepted, and some of which you refuse to. whether you misunderstood brian, or brian messed up in his teaching is moot. though i've never been to harry's, they teach the same thing that jimmy's does, and i've been to jimmy's for a bunch of years in a row now (no, not for my varsity letterman jacket.) both schools teach out of the red book, and the red book says PU covers on a tag up only with R1 and R2, and not with R2 only.

Welcome back "Bobby". How are you feeling these days?