Had to dump 3...or did I?

[jkumpire]

Tommy,

I understand quite clearly what you are seeing, and what you are getting at. But whether it is accidental or not, R3 is the guy responsible from contact and/or altering the play of the fielder. The throw and how F2 picked it up did not alter his chance to get the guy at 1B, R3 did.

That is why it is a clear FPSR violation. And I am sure you would have had a big yelling match with the offense in this case, but sometimes accidents happen and people get in trouble for them. Tough break.