Dead ball... Ball!

[DG]

Originally Posted by GarthB

To avoid a name calling episode, I won't name the particular ML umpire involved, but I was taught that the unwritten rule was to balance the need for the batter to avoid being hit with his right to not expect a pitch in the batter's box. The suggested criteria was that if he "prepared" for the hit or moved into it in any way, keep him in the box. Anything else...send him to first.

Does standing still, not making any effort qualify as "preparing" for the hit?