Batter out of box

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

2. I have worked some very high caliber ball, and some pretty good games at that. I have also worked lesser games in which a player has hit the ball while obviously outside of the box. So blatant, that not to call it would be a disservice to the game.

Maybe this is part of the answer to the dilemma. I don't think Tee has worked a game lower than HS varsity, for example (but I might be remembering incorrectly).

I have called this violation a couple of times in my career -- at the 13/14 Pony level, and at the Frosh HS level. Both were blatant violations.

As I've moved up, I've not made the call. Maybe the players are better than to commit a blatant violation. Maybe the play is faster so I can't see the violation. Maybe it's just not happened. Maybe the players and coaches don't whine for the obscure, no-advantage call (complaints about such calls as F-3 being in foul territory, not tagging the base runner when the ball is down in plenty of time, etc. also seem to diminish at the higher levels), so I'm not looking for it.

Does Evans say anything about the intent of the rule? Is it to restrict the batters feet on a ("normal") sacrifice bunt? Or is it to prevent moving way up or way back to hit a curve / Randy Johnson fastball? Or to prevent "not accepting" an intentional walk (and putting the ball in play when the defense probably isn't ready for it)? I think it's more likely to be the latter type of examples, but I don't know.