Overrun 1st on ball 4?

[Tim C]

Well now we are headed for the PU saying: "No, he didn't go!"

Still a mechanic I would never use, but it is acceptable and is taught.

I thought this group of astute readers would have already understood the issue of asking, or not: timing of request: and what can be offered when.

I just wanted to post a play that has odd possibilites.

But again, we see horribly untrained jv umpires answering in the most incorrect way possible.

If you don't say: "no he didn't go!", then you never have to worry about your pards saying something different.

Of course, this is just my opinion.