In the dirt or not?

[JasonTX]

I am in no way a baseball fan and I just happened to stop the channel surfing on the game and seen the play in question. The times I have watched baseball I have seen some plays where there were some definite catches, but the catchers still tagged the batter. This one should be on the shoulders of the catcher. When in doubt, no catch. Not sure if that's the rule for baseball, but that seems fair to me.