Lead-off Batter = On-Deck Batter?

[Manny A]

Okay, so this might sound like an inane question. But here goes:

NFHS. In between innings, how many batters may the offense have outside the dugout swinging a bat? As PU, I'm constantly policing areas in front of the offense's dugout when I see the lead-off batter and the upcoming on-deck batter taking their cuts. I tell them, "Only one batter out of the dugout, Coach." In response, I'm met with looks of utter confusion.

Looking at the NFHS rule book under 2-5-3, it says, "A single on-deck batter shall remain in her team's on-deck circle while the opposing pitcher is warming up." To me, that means the lead-off batter is the only player allowed outside the dugout swinging the bat.

Or does it?

The definition of On-deck Batter in 2-5-3 doesn't really help. It just says it's the player entitled to occupy the on-deck circle. Great; that's really on point...

[Big Slick]

Originally Posted by Manny A

Looking at the NFHS rule book under 2-5-3, it says, "A single on-deck batter shall remain in her team's on-deck circle while the opposing pitcher is warming up." To me, that means the lead-off batter is the only player allowed outside the dugout swinging the bat.

In PA, that's our interpretation. As an example, to start the game, the lead off hitter is the only one allowed in the on-deck circle while the home team is warming up. And taking this one step further, if there are no on-deck circles on the field (which is surprisingly all the schools in my county), no one is permitted on the field during warm ups.

Your state association may vary.

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by Big Slick

In PA, that's our interpretation. As an example, to start the game, the lead off hitter is the only one allowed in the on-deck circle while the home team is warming up. And taking this one step further, if there are no on-deck circles on the field (which is surprisingly all the schools in my county), no one is permitted on the field during warm ups.

Your state association may vary.

The rule does say "single on-deck batter" as quoted; but is this OOO.

However, I think the on deck circle like the batter box and other things exist even if there is no visible line.

[HugoTafurst]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

The rule does say "single on-deck batter" as quoted; but is this OOO.

However, I think the on deck circle like the batter box and other things exist even if there is no visible line.

Several years ago, our local commisioner advocated "no circle/no in-deck batter", but no one I know worries about that these days. We do keep them away from the batterers box an foul line.

On the other hand, I don't agree that enforcing the next batter only rule as emphasized by my State Association is OOO.

[Manny A]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

The rule does say "single on-deck batter" as quoted; but is this OOO.

It may be. But I've seen teams on occasion with more than two batters out there (e.g., lead-off, on-deck, in-the-hole). We've got to draw the line somewhere, or teams will just trot out their entire roster to take a few cuts as opposed to having them jog to the foul pole and back.

I was just trying to verify NFHS's intent here. The rule book doesn't make it clear if only the lead-off batter, or the lead-off batter and the on-deck batter, is allowed.

[Andy]

The lead off batter each inning is the current batter. The on deck batter is the one who follows her. I have always allowed both of them out of the dugout between innings, but no more than those two. Never been instructed otherwise.

We had a local 12u coach a few years back that wanted his entire team out of the dugout swinging bats between innings as an intimidation factor. We put an end to that pretty quick....

[Dutch Alex]

Originally Posted by Andy

The lead off batter each inning is the current batter. The on deck batter is the one who follows her. I have always allowed both of them out of the dugout between innings, but no more than those two. Never been instructed otherwise.

We had a local 12u coach a few years back that wanted his entire team out of the dugout swinging bats between innings as an intimidation factor. We put an end to that pretty quick....

Andy,
In red I've highlighted where you go wrong in my opinion. In between innings there's no current batter. Because no batter is allowed in the battersbox. So the first up to bat is the on-deck batter. In our competition and in ESF players looked very surprised when we started to enforce the rule more strictly. However now days no extra players come out. If they do, we just warn them and it's over...

[AtlUmpSteve]

Originally Posted by Andy

The lead off batter each inning is the current batter. The on deck batter is the one who follows her. I have always allowed both of them out of the dugout between innings, but no more than those two. Never been instructed otherwise.

We had a local 12u coach a few years back that wanted his entire team out of the dugout swinging bats between innings as an intimidation factor. We put an end to that pretty quick....

I think you are thinking the NCAA rule (which I prefer, actually). It is clear that between innings, two and only two people can be swinging bats on the field; the batter must be in foul territory and outside the batters box (and you can decide how far), and the (then) on-deck batter, to be in the on-deck circle.

So far as ASA and NFHS, I have a simpler way of looking at it, since there is no clear allowance like NCAA. Until I say (or can say; if not said, it isn't until I sweep the plate after the catcher throws down to 2nd) "batter up", no one is currently a batter [ASA 7-1.C(1), NFHS 7-5-3-a, and 2-5-3]; the first person to bat is still on-deck until that point. At the same time, if they stay over by the on-deck circle and not into the "space" to "time the pitches", I am prone to ignoring the second "on-deck" batter, similar to the NCAA allowance; just not more than that.

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

The rule does say "single on-deck batter" as quoted; but is this OOO.

However, I think the on deck circle like the batter box and other things exist even if there is no visible line.

This is not over-officious at all. It is a safety concern and safety ought to be your first priority. Umpires need to enforce the rule without fault. On-deck circle exist for a reason. Team members shouldn't have to worry about when another on-deck batter may come out and swing illegally.

If you see it and let it go and someone gets hurt, good luck.

[tcannizzo]

Originally Posted by EsqUmp

on-deck batter may come out and swing illegally.

Can't definition of Illegal Swing.

[DaveASA/FED]

I'm coming a little late to the party here but I agree only one player with a bat out of the dugout. And I'm pretty sure that was the intent from NFHS with regard to how the rule is inforced. Again a safety issue, somewhere the 2nd batter due up that inning hit the lead off batter in the back of the head with a practice swing knocking her out.

As it has been told to me one circle, one batter in it. Funny story about that, ASA 18U GOLD qualifier in my state last year I enforced this and got the 'are you kidding me' sort of response and 'never heard that before' etc. After telling the coach a second time and him getting more arguementitive I asked him "do you REALLY want to argue this with me?" He finally realized this was a moot point and not that big of a deal and not worth fighting over. So now fast forward ahead a couple of months and move to OKC at the GOLD Championship. Guess who the plate umpire is for this same teams 2nd pool play game....yep Karma is a weird thing huh? Was hilarious, coach recognized me and after the plate conference I heard him walk up to his dugout and say "Ok girls only one batter out of the dugout swinging a bat at a time." I had to laugh, guess he figured out it wasn't worth fighting over in that couple months!!

[HugoTafurst]

FHSAA clinics I have attended made it clear that only rhe next batter is allowed out between innings (1 player or however you want to say it).
I remember a clinic where one of the teams was asked to intentionally put two players out to see the response of the umpires being evaluated...
(I passed that part of the evaluation).