What would you have done?

[Dakota]

I agree with Rachel's comments.

Originally posted by oppool
1. Am I not right that the PU should of still taken the APPEAL since a play had not take place??

No, you should have just gotten his information and you should have handled the appeal - it was your call, not his. But, yes, the appeal should have been honored.

2. Should I have explain more to the coach after the PU refused to listen to the APPEAL??

Given that you gave the call to your partner, he should have talked with the coach, especially since you did not agree with it. But, in the situation you were in, I think what you told the coach was appropriate.

3. Am I not wrong when I thought the PU should of just kept quiet after the inning and not discussed the matter further with the coach unless at least requested??

The PU shoulda kept his trap shut. Sounds like he was trying to make himself look good.