2012 ASA Umpire Manual Correction

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

LP just mentioned this very issue this morning during the Region 4 NUS.

Much ado about nothing? Wonder how many people noticed or would have done anything different because of it?

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Much ado about nothing? Wonder how many people noticed or would have done anything different because of it?

It'd be such a counterintuitive place for a plate umpire to go that I doubt anyone would have thought to do it.

But still, good housekeeping is good housekeeping.

[Steve M]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

It'd be such a counterintuitive place for a plate umpire to go that I doubt anyone would have thought to do it.

But still, good housekeeping is good housekeeping.

OK, I recognize that coming from D4 in Pennsylvania, I am not likely to see a national. Dave Persing, the D4 commisioner does not send umpires to nationals.
But, if I were working a 3-umpire crew at an ASA national, chances are really good that I'd follow that NCAA manual.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

It'd be such a counterintuitive place for a plate umpire to go that I doubt anyone would have thought to do it.

But still, good housekeeping is good housekeeping.

Agree. I guess it all depends on whether you think the "holding zone" is a given area or some place you are in order to observe and decide which way you need to go.

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Agree. I guess it all depends on whether you think the "holding zone" is a given area or some place you are in order to observe and decide which way you need to go.

To me, the "holding zone" is the area where you should be to let the play develop. It should be out of the way of the players, but close enough that you can easily get into position for the next call.

However, since ASA has frequently emphasized specific locations as being "the holding zones" at the National Umpire Schools and in the DVDs, I can see where some could misinterpret the holding zone statement to mean that they should come up the 3rd base line.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

To me, the "holding zone" is the area where you should be to let the play develop. It should be out of the way of the players, but close enough that you can easily get into position for the next call.

However, since ASA has frequently emphasized specific locations as being "the holding zones" at the National Umpire Schools and in the DVDs, I can see where some could misinterpret the holding zone statement to mean that they should come up the 3rd base line.

I agree. This seems to be an issue with some who believe the DVD is the bible and the end of discussion. I believe the DVD is a good base upon which you start and build. School instructors should be more flexible in training and evaluation. When I say that, I'm not talking about drastic variations, but a slight adjustments that are necessary to see the play to get the call right.

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

I agree. This seems to be an issue with some who believe the DVD is the bible and the end of discussion. I believe the DVD is a good base upon which you start and build. School instructors should be more flexible in training and evaluation. When I say that, I'm not talking about drastic variations, but a slight adjustments that are necessary to see the play to get the call right.

Actually, at the NUS in Burlington this weekend, emphasis was placed on getting to the right starting position, and adjusting as necessary. I thought DG and LP got that message out quite well.

I've only been to 3 NUSs, and DG and LP taught 2 of the 3. So I can't speak for what's being taught elsewhere, but that's the message we got from them both times.

[CecilOne]

Why do the 3 ump mechanics disdain the holding zone, or is it just the holding zone wording?