![]() |
2012 ASA Umpire Manual Correction
The following is from the body of a letter from KR:
In the 2012 Umpire Manual there is a wording mistake in the Three Umpire System in a few sections. These are, with a runner on 2B only, 1B and 2B, 2B and 3B and Bases Loaded in the sections of Ground Ball to the Infield, and Base Hit to the Outfield. The verbiage used in the Umpire Manual for the movement of the Plate Umpire in these situations is “Move out from behind the plate toward the “holding zone” in foul ground and read the play. As we all know there is no holding zone in a Three Umpire System so the wording could be misleading. It was originally used to describe the plate umpire moving out toward 3B or what we refer to the holding zone. The DVD in these situations says “The Plate Umpire should move out from behind the plate and read the play.” These are the words that will be changed in the 2013 Umpire Manual. This should also appear in the February clarifications.<O:p</O:p |
LP just mentioned this very issue this morning during the Region 4 NUS.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
But still, good housekeeping is good housekeeping. |
Quote:
But, if I were working a 3-umpire crew at an ASA national, chances are really good that I'd follow that NCAA manual. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
However, since ASA has frequently emphasized specific locations as being "the holding zones" at the National Umpire Schools and in the DVDs, I can see where some could misinterpret the holding zone statement to mean that they should come up the 3rd base line. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I've only been to 3 NUSs, and DG and LP taught 2 of the 3. So I can't speak for what's being taught elsewhere, but that's the message we got from them both times. |
Why do the 3 ump mechanics disdain the holding zone, or is it just the holding zone wording?
|
Quote:
In fact, moving up the line like that could be misinterpreted by the players and coaches. They could misinterpret it as the PU having the call instead of the 3BU, thus lessening the 3BU's credibility on a tight play at 3rd. There are times when it's advantageous for two umpires to move towards the same play (e.g., the PU trailing the BR with no runners on or a lone runner on 1st). This, however, would not be such a time. |
Quote:
To answer the previous question, I suspect it is more the wording. |
Quote:
Now if said partner is only 30' away? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:15am. |