intentionally dropped foul tip

[shipwreck]

Does intentionally dropping a foul tip fall under the same rule as intentionally dropping a fly ball? The reason I ask. Say you have a great strike out pitcher with a runner on base. A foul tip occurs with the runner stealing on the foul tip. The catcher sees she cannot throw out the runner for some reason so intentionally drops the foul tip to make it a foul ball, thus forcing the runner back. Thanks for your replies, Dave

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by shipwreck

Does intentionally dropping a foul tip fall under the same rule as intentionally dropping a fly ball? The reason I ask. Say you have a great strike out pitcher with a runner on base. A foul tip occurs with the runner stealing on the foul tip. The catcher sees she cannot throw out the runner for some reason so intentionally drops the foul tip to make it a foul ball, thus forcing the runner back. Thanks for your replies, Dave

If the catcher does not catch the pitch, it becomes a foul ball, and the ball is dead.

MTD, Sr.

[Dholloway1962]

Intentionally dropped fly ball deals with only a fair batted ball...8-2-J.

Now whether or not she controlled it is strictly judgement. If I really truly believe it is intentional, without any doubt at all, in my judgement she probably controlled it and lost it on the transfer, if you catch my drift

[MichaelVA2000]

Originally Posted by Dholloway1962

Intentionally dropped fly ball deals with only a fair batted ball...8-2-J.

Now whether or not she controlled it is strictly judgement. If I really truly believe it is intentional, without any doubt at all, in my judgement she probably controlled it and lost it on the transfer, if you catch my drift

How does your "drift" handle the DC when you judge that F1 dropped the pitch on the transfer and you leave the runner at second base?

[wadeintothem]

No its not illegal.

Anymore than it would be illegal for superman to play on a team and fly into the air and catch a home run...

or any other impossible thing.

[Dholloway1962]

Originally Posted by MichaelVA2000

How does your "drift" handle the DC when you judge that F1 dropped the pitch on the transfer and you leave the runner at second base?

I tell him that in my judgement she controlled the ball and we have a foul tip.

[whiskers_ump]

Originally Posted by shipwreck

Does intentionally dropping a foul tip fall under the same rule as intentionally dropping a fly ball? The reason I ask. Say you have a great strike out pitcher with a runner on base. A foul tip occurs with the runner stealing on the foul tip. The catcher sees she cannot throw out the runner for some reason so intentionally drops the foul tip to make it a foul ball, thus forcing the runner back. Thanks for your replies, Dave

Proving she dropped it would be the toughest sell in the book.

[MichaelVA2000]

Originally Posted by whiskers_ump

Proving she dropped it would be the toughest sell in the book.

Amen to that!

[jimpiano]

Originally Posted by shipwreck

Does intentionally dropping a foul tip fall under the same rule as intentionally dropping a fly ball? The reason I ask. Say you have a great strike out pitcher with a runner on base. A foul tip occurs with the runner stealing on the foul tip. The catcher sees she cannot throw out the runner for some reason so intentionally drops the foul tip to make it a foul ball, thus forcing the runner back. Thanks for your replies, Dave

What a stupid question.

[7in60]

Originally Posted by jimpiano

What a stupid reply.

Fixed.

[LMan]

Originally Posted by 7in60

Fixed.

Not really.


You think a F2 can 1) react to a foul-tip ball "sharp and direct" back to her in a fraction of a second, then 2) judge her inability to throw out a runner, in time to 3) drop the ball without it looking deliberate? All of this in about 1 second?


There's TWPs, and then there's like mission-to-Mars plays. This one is at least close to the Moon.

[7in60]

Originally Posted by LMan

Not really.


You think a F2 can 1) react to a foul-tip ball "sharp and direct" back to her in a fraction of a second, then 2) judge her inability to throw out a runner, in time to 3) drop the ball without it looking deliberate? All of this in about 1 second?


There's TWPs, and then there's like mission-to-Mars plays. This one is at least close to the Moon.

Solution: don't close the glove.

There's no way the PU could judge this. He/she sees the ball on the ground, it's a foul ball.

There are no stupid questions.

[whiskers_ump]

Originally Posted by MichaelVA2000

How does your "drift" handle the DC when you judge that F1 dropped the pitch on the transfer and you leave the runner at second base?

Cause she stole the base?

[wadeintothem]

It would be easier for her to use telekenisis and mind control that ball to the ground than intentionally drop a foul tip just because a runner that the catcher is "scared of" is stealing.

You guys picked a bad day to stop sniffing glue.

You guys have actually seen a softball game right? If not that, at least glanced at baseball or something?

Cool sports, give it a try.

[shipwreck]

Wade, just because you are closing in on 2000 posts doesn't mean all the answers you give are correct. I didn't realize questions like mine cannot be asked here. Wish I was perfect like you are. Dave