Batter's box

[Rita C]

Originally Posted by BretMan

It's not really spelled out in the Rule Book, aside from the requirements that say the batter must be "within the box".

There are, however, three plays in the Case Book that fully describe what constitutes being "in the box" (it's the same as OBR).

The Case Plays are 7.3.2 A, B & C.

(*Edited to add: Have you ever had one of those "DUH" moments? I just did, when I realized that I was on the SOFTBALL board and not the BASEBALL board. Oddly, the Case Plays in the FED baseball and softball books are nearly identical! Not only that, they are under the same play number- 7.3.2).

Thank you! It's been a few years since I did HS softball.

I need this because I was told I didn't know what I was talking about yesterday while leading a mechanics clinic. Four senior umpires told me I was wrong (I am also a senior umpire.) when I said the batter needed to stay in the box before the pitch.

Rita

[BretMan]

Aside from the part about hitting the ball with a foot touching the plate, and the obvious dimensional differences, I believe that the rules covering the batter's box and the batter being in it are pretty much universal between all baseball and softball rule sets.

At least, I can't think of any major differences...

[CajunNewBlue]

I am a little curious as to and in what context you said "the batter must "stay" in the box before the pitch" and were told you were incorrect by that many senior umpires? If only for my own curiosity. I quoted the word "stay" because that means the batter was already in the box and then might decide to leave the box. (and i dont know how to make bold letters )

[Rita C]

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

I am a little curious as to and in what context you said "the batter must "stay" in the box before the pitch" and were told you were incorrect by that many senior umpires? If only for my own curiosity. I quoted the word "stay" because that means the batter was already in the box and then might decide to leave the box. (and i dont know how to make bold letters )

I should have used the word "stand" maybe? In any case, we were discussing what to do with a batter whose toes were overhanging and nearing the plate.

Rita

[CajunNewBlue]

toes overhanging and nearing the plate.... hrmmm, me I got nothing, provided that the rest of the batters foot/feet are on the line. Is this correct?

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

toes overhanging and nearing the plate.... hrmmm, me I got nothing, provided that the rest of the batters foot/feet are on the line. Is this correct?

Prior to the pitch? No, it is not. The batter's feet must be completely inside the batter's box prior to the pitch. On the line is "in the box".

However, since there is 6" between the edge of the plate and batter's box, if the batter's feet are anywhere near the plate, s/he is not in the box.

[CajunNewBlue]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Prior to the pitch? No, it is not. The batter's feet must be completely inside the batter's box prior to the pitch. On the line is "in the box".

However, since there is 6" between the edge of the plate and batter's box, if the batter's feet are anywhere near the plate, s/he is not in the box.

ok call me confused or did you just contradict yourself? if the toes are "over hanging" (i would assume overhanging the line) that mean some of the foot is on the line ..and if on the line is in the box. how could my earlier observation be wrong?
I don't know what Rita's meaning of near the plate is, 1" or 2" or whatever..... take a pretty dang small foot to not be partly on the line and be near the plate. ( I dont want to get caught up on distances to the plate as they are irrelavant... the point of focus to my thinking is the other part of the foot and the line)