Does your assignor grade you?

[argodad]

Originally Posted by JPRempe

I like the GUA system, which is basically what you have described. They have specific evaluators, and a specific assignor. Works pretty well, in my opinion.

The Florida HS system also requires a separate evaluation committee, along with training, grievance, recommendations, and assignment committees. (The assignment committee ensures that the booking agent is fair in his assignments.) If your association is blessed with enough good umpires who care, it works well.